The PE Rule of 20 for SA Equities

By Christo Luüs
Third Circle Asset Management

ver the years investment analysts have created many “rules of thumb” to determine whether an equity market is over or under-valued. One of the more popular is the so-called “rule of 20” which states that an equity market of which the sum of the country’s inflation rate and its PE ratio is below 20, can be considered cheap. This rule can allegedly be applied to most markets where there is no hyper-inflation.
The relationship between inflation and a market’s PE ratio may not be immediately apparent. It may even be argued that the price/earnings ratio is a “real” concept, since both share prices (the numerator) and company earnings (the denominator) are subject to inflation. It might therefore be assumed that PE ratios, being a real concept, can always be compared across markets, regardless of inflation rates.
However, the rule of 20 would have it that low inflation countries will usually have higher PE ratios than high inflation countries. The logic of this is easy to see if one bears in mind that it can be mathematically proven that the PE ratio depends on three variables: the dividend payout ratio; the nominal growth rate in dividends; and investors’ required rate of nominal return. Inflation thus enters the PE equation through the required return – the higher the inflation rate, the higher the nominal return that investors would require, and the lower would be the PE ratio.
Argued more intuitively, one needs to keep in mind that the PE ratio in effect tells us how much an investor is willing to pay for every rand of earnings generated by a company. Put differently, the PE ratio tells us how many years an investor will have to wait before he recovers his payment for the share in terms of current annual earnings. Under a high inflation scenario, an investor will typically want to recover his investment faster (nominal earnings growth would be rising by more) and he would therefore want to pay less for every rand of earnings that the company generates.

To test whether the rule of 20 would indeed have given buying (or selling) signals for the SA All-share index, the Alsi PE-ratio and inflation rate were added and plotted for the past 37 years. There were clearly times when the Alsi+inflation line deviated quite far from the “20-line”. Some of these points were marked and the graph and the average annualised monthly return on the Alsi was measured over the 24-months period following the over-valued or under-valued signal. The results are shown in the table.
PE ratios, as well as the rule of 20, are of course over-simplifications of the investment decision process and they do not take account of differences between companies, sectors, or markets. But this rule does provide a quick measure to give an investor some comfort that he or she is not overpaying for a share (or more appropriately – an index) without good reason. The current Alsi PE ratio and inflation sum is very close to 20, as opposed to the late-2003 to mid-2004 period which clearly constituted a buying opportunity.
Inflation is set to increase to close to 6% by year-end, while interest rates may have to rise by early-2012 at the latest. These developments, together with a struggling domestic and global economy, are usually not supportive of company earnings. It therefore remains unclear whether a buying opportunity – based on the rule of 20 – will arise soon. However, proper asset allocation and diversification remain key principles of ensuring continued and steady portfolio growth even in the absence of clear indications that buying opportunities exist.