JP Morgan Chase: beaching the London whale
By Ingrid Goodspeed
Governor of the Institute of Financial Markets

n 10 May 2012 JP Morgan Chase (JP Morgan) announced a USD 2 billion (ZAR 16.5 billion) trading loss.The sharpest criticism of the loss came from the bank's chief executive, Jamie Dimon who said the loss was the result of “sloppiness”, “poor judgment” and “stupidity” on the part of the bank.

JP Morgan is the US’s largest banking group by assets (USD 2 trillion) and is renowned for the quality of its risk management. The bank is credited with being the first bank to use value-at-risk (VaR) as a risk measure. The bank’s use of VaR is said to have originated when Dennis Weatherstone, at the time the Chairman of JP Morgan, asked the question that is the basis for VaR namely: How much can we lose on our trading portfolio by tomorrow’s close? The result was the so-called 4.15 report, a daily one-page report that showed the potential losses over the next 24 hours across all the bank’s trading portfolios by aggregating different trading positions on the basis of a single consistent risk measure namely VaR.

Although there has been limited detailed disclosure about its loss from JP Morgan, probably to protect its ability to unwind its positions, it would appear the event occurred as follows:

The trader responsible for the trades is Bruno Iksil dubbed the London whale due to the size of his trades. He worked in JP Morgan’s Chief Investment Office (CIO). The CIO’s primary responsibility is to manage an approximately USD350 billion portfolio in a conservative manner by investing excess liabilities and managing long-term interest rate and currency exposure. It also maintains a synthetic credit portfolio to hedge the bank against a systemic event, like the financial crisis or Eurozone sovereign defaults. The synthetic credit portfolio was designed to generate modest returns in a benign credit environment and more substantial returns in a stressed environment.

The July 2012 internal investigation into the activities of the CIO by JP Morgan found that:

The losses at JP Morgan have intensified debate around certain issues that are uppermost in the minds of regulators and policy makers:

It is likely that the scale and unforeseen nature of JP Morgan’s USD 2 billion loss may accelerate plans by global policymakers to (i) strengthen capital standards for market risk and ensure that regulatory capital is sufficient in periods of significant market stress and (ii) require banks to improve their trading risk management and models. The ultimate purpose is a more resilient banking sector. However can this be achieved without a move away from a culture characterised by greed, obfuscation and exploitation to one of service, integrity and long-term commitment to consumers and other stakeholders?


(1) Owing to the size, interconnectedness, or complexity of systemically important financial institutions negative externalities emanating from their financial distress makes them a source of systemic risk and lead to them being perceived to be too-important-to-fail.
(2) In its fundamental review of the trading book consultative document of the Basel Committee on Bank Supervision proposed the replacement of VaR by expected shortfall

Bibliography

Basel Committee on Banking Supervision. May 2012.  Fundamental review of the trading book. www.bis.org
Carver, L. 14 May 2012. JP Morgan’s London whale losses spark VaR debate. www.risk.net
Pollack, L. 19 June 2012. JPM whale-watching tour. www.ft.com
Rimkus, R. 17 May 2012. JP Morgan and the London Whale: understanding the hedge that wasn’t. http://blogs.cfainstitute.org/investor/2012/05/17/jpmorgan-chase-and-the-london-whale
Short, G. Murphy, EV and Miller, RS. 16 August 2012. JP Morgan trading losses: implications for the Volcker rule and other regulation. Congressional Research Service
Testimony of Jamie Dimon Chairman & CEO, JP Morgan Chase & Co. before the U.S. Senate  Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Washington, D.C. June 13, 2012
Wutkowski, K. 14 June 2012. Bair decries hyperventilation over JP Morgan loss. www.reuters.com