Introduction
he mysterious Satoshi Nakamoto, which is a pseudonym for a single programmer or group of programmers, published a paper in 2008 introducing Bitcoin(1) as a “peer-to-peer electronic cash system” that enables online payments directly between two parties without the intermediation of a trusted third party like a bank. A year later the technical design set out by Satoshi was implemented using open source software and the first peer-to-peer transfer of bitcoins took place on 12 January 2009.
The first real bitcoin transaction was in May 2010 when a US programmer bought a pizza for 10 000 bitcoins (then about USD 25, now over USD 5 million). The use of bitcoins grew throughout 2011 and 2012 together with and in spite of increasing incidents of hacking and theft. But it was in early 2013 that Bitcoin hit mainstream news headlines, where it has remained ever since for reasons including substantial price volatility; allegations that bitcoins are being used illicitly as well as for purposes of money laundering; increasing incidents of hacking and theft of bitcoins; growing scrutiny around whether or what regulatory oversight is required and how bitcoin transactions are to be viewed by tax authorities across the globe.
Before 2013 bitcoins were priced at less than USD 20. Since then their price has risen substantially and fluctuated wildly, hitting a high of USD 1 151 in December 2013 and falling to just over USD 533 on 16 April 2014 (see figure 1).
The objectives of this article are to (i) outline the characteristics of the Bitcoin economy; (ii) give an overview of the Bitcoin system including the risks and benefits of using bitcoins; (iii) report on the response to Bitcoin by authorities in a number of jurisdictions including South Africa (iv) briefly discuss the controversies surrounding Bitcoin and (v) conclude by speculating on the future of Bitcoin.
Figure 1: Bitcoin market price in USD

The high-level characteristics of the Bitcoin economy can be summarised as follows:
The Bitcoin system is a virtual currency system that operates on a decentralised peer-to-peer network. All activities such as transaction processing and verification are managed collectively by the network. Figure 2 is a pictorial representation of how the system works.
Figure 2: How the Bitcoin system works

All bitcoin transactions are recorded in a shared and permanent public database or ledger called the block-chain. New bitcoins are created when a new block, comprising several transactions, is attached to the block-chain through a process known as mining. A new block is only added to the block-chain once a complex cryptographic algorithm is solved by a miner for a reward of, currently, 25(3) bitcoins.
Solving the algorithm confirms the validity of the block’s transactions by proving mathematically that the transactions occurred and are not the double spending of bitcoins. Transactions are for all intents and purposes irreversible once committed to the block-chain. Since 2009 there have been over 37 million bitcoin transactions and the block-chain comprised 16 316 blocks on 16 April 2014.
The Bitcoin system will allow a maximum of 21 million bitcoins to be created and placed in circulation, which is estimated to happen in 2140. There are currently (16 April 2014) 12.7 million bitcoins in circulation. The total balance held in bitcoins is currently around USD 7 billion (compared with USD 1 200 billion circulating in U.S. currency).
Over time, mining has become and will continue to be less unprofitable. As an incentive, bitcoin users may voluntarily offer miners transaction fees as additional reward, which means bitcoin transactions will no longer be near-zero cost. Once the limit of 21 million bitcoins is reached, transaction verification and processing can only be rewarded by fees.
Bitcoin users obtain bitcoins by (i) buying those already in circulation from others or through a bitcoin exchange; (ii) accepting them as payment for goods and services; or (iii) mining.
Bitcoin users carry out bitcoin transactions by sending digitally-signed messages with the addresses of the bitcoin sender and receiver to the Bitcoin network. Each address contains two cryptographic keys: the public key (commonly called the address) and the private key. The private key is stored in a virtual wallet and is known only to the bitcoin owner(4). It is used to prove the bitcoin owner’s right to spend bitcoins from the wallet through a cryptographic digital signature affixed to a transaction. The public key is public information and is used by miners to validate transactions and that the bitcoins are not being spent more than once.
Once the user’s transaction is recognised by the Bitcoin network miners process it by adding it to the block of recently received transactions. Blocks are added to the block-chain (after solving the algorithm) at a rate of about one block every ten minutes. To maintain the rate of one block per 10 minutes (and thereby avoid flooding the market with new bitcoins), the difficulty of the algorithm increases as the total computational power of the miners in the network grows. The recent increase in difficulty has been extreme- the difficulty factor increased by 77 665% between April 2013 and April 2014.
Bitcoins offer users a number of benefits:
There are also a number of disadvantages to using bitcoins including:
Bitcoin has not escaped the notice of governments across the world. Table 1 below shows the response from the financial sector as well as taxation authorities of a number of countries.
Table 1: The response of governments to Bitcoin |
||
Country |
Financial sector authorities |
Taxation authorities |
Australia |
There are no restrictions on holding or transacting in other currencies, including bitcoin. (Reserve Bank of Australia) |
Bitcoin will be subject to the same taxation requirements that apply to conventional commercial transactions, including the Goods and Services Tax. (Australian Taxation Office) |
Brazil |
Given the low volume of bitcoin transactions and its reduced acceptance as a medium of exchange the use of virtual coins offers no risk to the Brazilian financial system. Once such risk arises, the use of virtual currencies will be regulated. (Central Bank of Brazil) |
|
Canada |
Smaller, stand-alone payment systems for which there are many substitutes – like Bitcoin – generally require less intensive oversight and regulation because they pose less risk to the Canadian financial system. (Bank of Canada) |
Users of bitcoins will pay tax on bitcoin transactions based on tax rules that apply to barter transactions and things that are bought and sold for speculative purposes. (Canadian Revenue Agency) |
China |
Bitcoin is a special virtual commodity, not a currency and should not be circulated and used as a currency. Individuals are free to buy and sell Bitcoin but at their own risk. Banks and payment institutions are prohibited from dealing in bitcoins. China is considering instructing banks to close bitcoin trading accounts. This would close the remaining channel by which people in China buy bitcoins. |
|
European Union |
Bitcoin shares certain characteristics with European payment systems but does not fall within the regulation of such systems. However Bitcoin does fall within the responsibility of the central bank. (European Central Bank) Consumers have been warned that since bitcoin is not regulated, buying, holding or trading bitcoin (and other virtual currencies) have a number of risks including incurring tax liabilities in their home country; having their money stolen from their digital wallets; making losses if the price of the currency falls, maybe to zero; being party to criminal activities including money laundering. (European Banking Authority) |
The German government categorises bitcoin as a unit of account, thus recognising it as subject to capital gains tax. Other countries in the European Union may follow suit. |
South Africa |
Bitcoin has neither legal status nor a regulatory framework. As such it poses risks for consumers who hold or trade it as its convertibility and value is not guaranteed. (South African Reserve Bank) |
The developments around Bitcoin are being monitored especially within the environment of increasing e-commerce. (South African Revenue Services) |
Thailand |
Bitcoin transactions are illegal. This includes buying and selling bitcoins, buying goods and services for bitcoins, selling goods and services in exchange for bitcoins, sending bitcoins to or receiving bitcoins from anyone outside of the country. (Bank of Thailand) |
|
United Kingdom |
Bitcoins are not currently widely used as a medium of exchange. Instead, their popularity largely derives from their ability to serve as an asset class and as such have more similarities to commodities such as gold, than money. (Bank of England) |
VAT will be payable from suppliers of any goods or services sold in exchange for Bitcoin or other similar crypto-currency. The value of the supply of goods or services on which VAT is due will be the sterling value of the crypto-currency at the point the transaction takes place. (Her Majesty’s Revenue & Customs) |
United States |
Real currency is defined as the coin and paper money of the US or of any other country that (i) is designated as legal tender, (ii) circulates and (iii) is customarily used and accepted as a medium of exchange in the country of issuance. Bitcoins do not have all the attributes of a real currency because they do not have legal tender status in any jurisdiction. However as a medium of exchange bitcoins operate as a real currency in some environments and have either (i) an equivalent value in real currency or (ii) act as substitute for real currency. (U.S. Financial Crimes Enforcement Network) |
Bitcoin will be treated as property for federal tax purposes. Capital gains tax will apply: gains will be taxable and losses deductible. (Internal Revenue Services) |
Since its origination in 2009, Bitcoin has had its share of controversy. A number of these are:
1.Is bitcoin money?
Economists suggest money has three functions: medium of exchange, store of value and unit of account. As a medium of exchange money is generally and consistently accepted in exchange for goods and services. As a store of value money is expected to retain its value over time reasonably and predictably. As a unit of account money is a standard numerical yardstick for the measurement of value in an economy such as the costs of goods, services, assets and liabilities.
Currencies such as the USD, EUR, YEN, GBP or ZAR meet all three requirements, bitcoins not yet. While bitcoins are a medium of exchange, they are not generally accepted. Since the value of bitcoins is subject to substantial volatility, they cannot be considered a stable store of value. Bitcoins are not a unit of account, even the few retailers that accept them as payment for goods and services use other currencies as their principal units of account.
2.Is Bitcoin technology sufficiently robust?
Bitcoin technology has a number of vulnerabilities. One is transaction malleability, which allows a valid transaction to be changed and re-made, sending the bitcoins to a user other than the intended beneficiary. If the altered transaction is confirmed by the Bitcoin network first, the real transaction disappears. If the intended beneficiary reports non-receipt of the bitcoins, the user may send the transaction again and suffer loss. MtGox blamed transaction malleability for its loss of 750 000 bitcoins. However Bitcoin programmers have been aware of transaction malleability since 2011 and it is surprising that MtGox did not protect itself from being hacked in this way.
A further vulnerability is to vast numbers of small transactions, which slow the network down as there is one block-chain serving as the ledger for the entire Bitcoin network.
Since Bitcoin’s programming is open source, any programmer can voluntarily check the software for flaws and suggest fixes. However it is doubtful whether relying exclusively on volunteers to validate fixes is sustainable in the longer term especially when large value amounts and volumes are concerned. The Heartbleed (5) bug is an example of how validation failure can result in the potential exposure of sensitive user information.
3.Is Bitcoin’s design sustainable and scalable?
The process of mining that creates bitcoins and ensures the integrity and processing of bitcoin transactions has led to a race to establish computing power to solve algorithms. It is estimated that Bitcoin’s decentralised computational foundation has reached more than 50 000 petaflops (6). Mining has reached the point where only commercial and professional miners with server farms can continue operations and then only at marginal returns. If the returns from mining (including the current voluntary fees paid by users) are insufficient to compensate miners for their work, who will verify the integrity of the block-chain?
Furthermore every user in the Bitcoin system keeps a copy of the block-chain, which is now 16.3 gigabytes(7) and growing and can take more than a day to download. This imposes significant and widespread overhead and may discourage casual use of Bitcoin by both existing and potential users.
4.Bitcoin and criminal activity
Bitcoin and other virtual currencies are being abused by professional criminals and have allegedly become the preferred way to buy drugs and other contraband too nefarious to mention. A few bitcoin-related criminal events, including hacking and theft are listed below. The current USD amount of bitcoin losses is valued at USD 533 (16 April 2014).
In June 2011 Allinvain, a member of the Bitcoin Talk forums became the first person to suffer a bitcoin hack, when 25 000 bitcoins were stolen, then valued at USD 0.5 million, today at USD 13 million.
In July 2011 78 739 bitcoins were stolen from MyBitcoin. The theft resulted in its closure. It is alleged that this event was not a theft but a scam by its operator. Nonetheless users lost their bitcoins.
In October 2011 Bitcoin7, a new bitcoin exchange, was hacked resulting in the theft of 11 000 bitcoins. Bitcoin7 shut down as a result.
In October 2013 the FBI closed down Silk Road, an illicit marketplace for narcotics, assassinations and pornography set up in February 2011 and powered by bitcoins. From February 2011 to July 1.2 million transactions were completed for 9.5 million bitcoins (USD 5.1 billion).
During 2011 and 2012 Bitcoin Savings and Trust, founded and operated by Trendon Shavers, offered and sold bitcoin-denominated investments. It raised at least 700 000 bitcoins (USD 372 million). In July 2013 the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC) charged Mr Shavers with defrauders investors in a Ponzi scheme in which bitcoins from new investors were (i) used to make interest payments (at a promised rate of 7% weekly or 364% p.a.) and cover investor withdrawals on existing investments with Bitcoin Savings and Trust and (ii) exchanged into USD to pay Mr Shavers personal expenses. On 23 July 2013 the SEC issued a warning to investors about the risks of potential investment scams involving bitcoins and other virtual currencies.
Bitcoinia survived its first hacking event in March 2012 but not the second in May 2012. The firm closed its website and promised to pay its customers 50% of their holdings. Its holdings remained dormant in an account at MtGox while finalising the legal situation. When MtGox closed its doors in 2013, Bitcoinia’s customers finally lost everything.
In October 2013, an Australian bitcoin “bank” was hacked, resulting in the theft of 4 100 bitcoins valued at over USD 2 million. The service’s operator was a teenager, clearly not an average 3-6-3 banker(8).
MtGox(9) the largest Bitcoin exchange was hacked for the first time in June 2011. The hacker compromised a MtGox account and made a massive sale of bitcoins, causing the value of a bitcoin to fall from USD 32 to less than USD 1. MtGox was hacked again in February 2013 when it lost all its bitcoin holdings: 750 000 bitcoins (although 200 000 bitcoins were later found in an “old wallet”). Early in 2014 MtGox filed for bankruptcy.
In March 2014 a Canadian bitcoin bank Flexcoin was hacked and robbed of 896 bitcoins (valued at about USD 480 000). The bank announced that it did not have the resources to recover from the loss and was closing its doors.
What does the future hold for Bitcoin? To succeed in the same or different form; to fade away; to be overtaken by competitors(10); to remain a novel experiment used by only avid supporters; to succumb to a fundamental and catastrophic breach that undermines it completely; or to be regulated into oblivion.
The Internet was not generally considered a practical technology in the 1980s. But as an open platform it allowed innovation from anyone enabled by it and in the long run it proved to be a miraculous low-cost technology that is rapidly and dramatically changing the world. Perhaps Bitcoin will evolve into such a generally-accepted and trusted service. Testimony by the then Federal Reserve Vice Chairman Alan Blinder as long ago as 1995 (repeated in November 2013 by the then Federal Reserve Chairman Ben Bernanke), might hold the key to the future of Bitcoin technology “while these types of innovations may pose risks related to law enforcement and supervisory matters, there are also areas in which they may hold long-term promise, particularly if the innovations promote a faster, more secure and more efficient payment system”. Maybe the future for Bitcoin technology lies not in being an alternative currency, but in its decentralized open-source platform, with low barriers to entry, which could form a low-cost backbone for peer-to-peer financial and other transactions across the globe. Surely JP Morgan Chase has recognised this, as late 2013 it filed a US patent application for a payment system that resembles aspects of Bitcoin technology in that it will allow people to make anonymous peer-to-peer payments over the Internet.
Bitcoin was developed in part to escape the limitations of traditional currency, notably government control. As pointed out in the European Central Bank’s paper on virtual currency schemes one of the reasons behind virtual currency schemes is to compete with traditional currencies, such as the EUR and USD. Surely then there are deeper questions that should be on the agenda of policymakers, academics, technologists, and society in general. Such as those expressed by Ron Paul in 2012 “The world is in the midst of a crisis today, and many of us believe it is related to a deeply flawed monetary system, a deeply flawed understanding of what money should be, a rejection of the notion that money should have real value and that money originated in the marketplace rather than originating from a computer over at the Federal Reserve.”
Real currency is generally accepted as payment for goods and services and is backed by government, which ensures demand for the currency by accepting it as payment for tax liabilities. Bitcoin on the other hand has no intrinsic value and is not backed by government. Thus it has value only because people are willing to accept it as a form of payment, and this willingness is not universal. As pointed out by the Economist “All currencies involve some measure of consensual hallucination, but Bitcoin involves more than most”.
Bank of England (Michael McLeay, Amar Radia and Ryland Thomas of the Bank’s Monetary Analysis Directorate). 2014. Money in the modern economy: an introduction. Available wwwbankofengland.co.uk. Accessed April 2014.
Bernanke Ben. November 2013. Letter to the Committee on Homeland Security and Governmental Affairs. Available https://www.documentcloud.org/documents/835843-virtual-currency-hearings.html. Accessed April 2014.
European Banking Authority. December 2013. Warning to consumers on virtual currencies. Available www.eba.europa.eu/documents/10180/598344/EBA+Warning+on+Virtual+Currencies.pdf. Accessed April 2014.
European Central Bank. October 2012. Virtual currency schemes. Available at www.ecb.europa.eu. Accessed April 2014.
Government Accountability Office. May 2013. Virtual economies and currencies. Available www.gao.gov. Accessed April 2014.
Gustav Stolper, 1942. This Age of Fable in the Political and Economic World. New York: Reynal & Hitchcock.
Her Majesty’s Revenue and Customs. March 2014. Revenue and Customs Brief 09/14: Tax treatment of activities involving Bitcoin and other similar cryptocurrencies. Available www.hmrc.gov.za. Accessed April 2014.
Law Library. January 2014. Regulation of Bitcoin in selected jurisdictions. Available www.law.gov. Accessed April 2014.
Mail & Guardian. 3 April 2014. Is virtual currency here to stay? Available www.mg.co.za. Accessed April 2014.
Satoshi Nakamoto. 2008. Bitcoin: a peer-to-peer electronic cash system. Available www.bitcoin.org. Accessed April 2014.
The Economist. 30 November 2013. Bitcoin under pressure. Available at http://www.economist.com/news/technology-quarterly/21590766-virtual-currency-it-mathematically-elegant-increasingly-popular-and-highly. Accessed April 2014.
The Economist. 15 March 2014. Hidden flipside. Available at http://www.economist.com/news/finance-and-economics/21599054-how-crypto-currency-could-become-internet-money-hidden-flipside. Accessed April 2014.
US Patent and Trademark Office. 28 November 2013. Method and system for processing internet payments using the electronic funds transfer network. Available http://appft.uspto.gov/netacgi/nph-Parser?Sect1=PTO2&Sect2=HITOFF&p=1&u=%2Fnetahtml%2FPTO%2Fsearch-bool.html&r=1&f=G&l=50&co1=AND&d=PG01&s1=20130317984&OS=20130317984&RS=20130317984. Accessed April 2014.
Data sources:
(1) “Bitcoin” (capitalised) refers to the technology, network and system while “bitcoin” (lower case) refers to the currency.
(2) The risk that a single unit of virtual currency is sent to two different recipients. It is a problem unique to virtual currencies as digital information is easily reproduced, which is not the case for physical currencies.
(3) The number of bitcoins issued as rewards to successful miners will halve every time the network attains 210,000 blocks, about every four years. From inception through November 2012, rewards were 50 bitcoins. In 2016, rewards are expected to be 12.5 bitcoins.
(4) If the bitcoin user loses, forgets or destroys the private key, the bitcoins are lost and cannot be replaced.
(5) The Heartbleed bug is a flaw in the OpenSSL software responsible for encrypting traffic on the Internet. SSL means secure sockets layer, which is a standard protocol for establishing an encrypted link between a server (generally a web server) and a client.
(6) One quadrillion (10 to the power of 15) floating point operations per second (flops). A person would have to do a mathematical calculation every second for more than 31 million years to match what a petaflops computer system can do in one second. Numbers too big to think about?
(7) One gigabyte is 10 to the power of 9 (1 000 000 000) bytes.
(8) Pay 3% interest on deposits, earn 6% interest on loans and be on the golf course by 3 p.m.
(9) MtGox stands for Magic the Gathering online exchange and was originally a site to trade cards for the game called Magic: the Gathering.
(10) There are a number of other cryptocurrencies in the market. Estimates range from 40 to over 100.