The Basics of carbon credit creation in the South African business sector, and where to next.
A brief introduction and a view on Carbon credit trading in South Africa
By Peter Oldacre

 

Just when we thought that it was safe to go back into the water, and that no one could create a more obscure financial instrument than a Gamma Hedged Convertible Bond, along comes the Kyoto Protocol which sets the World up for large scale CO2e emissions trading.

The Kyoto Protocol was some ten years in the making, and in its final form some 168 countries signed up and ratified that they would bring its constituent components into law. The practical idea was that the protocol separated the world into less developed and more developed nations, and created flexible instruments to allow and to encourage parties to reduce their Green House Gas emissions. The reduction of one tonne of CO2e has since then become more generically described as a carbon credit. A carbon credit is measured as one tonne of carbon dioxide equivalent that would have been emitted, but that now is reduced and encompasses six green house gasses, which are then reduced into the equivalent amount of CO2 equivalent, and the process by which a carbon credit is created is called a Clean Development Mechanism (CDM).

The six GHG’s are:

  1. Methane, which is 21 more times potent than CO2 when released into the atmosphere,
  2. N2O, which is 310m times more potent,
  3. SF6 which is 23 000 times more potent than CO2,
  4. HFC’s which range in potency up to 11 400 times more potent than CO2, and
  5. PFC’s which range form 6500 to 9 000 times more potent than CO2e.

Simplistically speaking, but in the search of an easy example: To reduce the amount of methane being emitted by an industrial plant in the order of one tonne, would result in the reduction of the equivalent of 21 tonnes of CO2, and accordingly generate 21 carbon credits. Not a perfect example, but as an indication of how the creation of a carbon credit comes about, not a bad example.

In terms of how Kyoto has been put together, the more developed nations effectively have an allowance of carbon that they could emit for free each year, and that allowance is negotiated once a year. If they were found to be emitting more than their allowance, a fine for each tonne of carbon over and above that allowable level was to be levied. The allowance gets reduced as the years go by, and the ultimate goal of Kyoto is to be able to reduce the amount of CO2e that is being released into the atmosphere to a level that is 5% below the amounts that were being emitted in 1990: not a lot in absolute terms, but it is a good start – and indeed a good start to a new industry.

If an industry, in a more developed nation, has the good fortune to be able to not only stay within their allowance, but can actually reduce their emissions to below their allowance, they can sell the amount of the allowance that they have not used. Here comes the financial instrument... At the moment these allowances are traded between developed nations at a price of around 22-00 Euro per tonne of CO2e.

Kyoto also allows for the less developed nations to partially trade into the same system. If an industry or an individual plant chooses to reduce their own carbon emissions, and that industry is situated in a less developed country through more efficient use of electricity, or the installation of more efficient processes. Even if they choose to capture and destroy some of the GHG that they may be emitting into the atmosphere, they can then sell that “reduction” in CO2e to the same buyers who are going to be over their allowed amount of allowance. This market is referred to as the compliance market as those industries that are not able to stay within their allowances are complied to physically abate and then to use the financial instrument to offset their emissions.

This is then the very simplified basics behind carbon credit trading. It must be said that Kyoto based mechanisms are not the only tradable emission reduction instruments, and although the number that Kyoto is trying to achieve is just a 5% reduction, the move to reduce emissions is a very new…and an incredibly large market that is just being born. Take as an example the UK, which is seen as a developed nation; take Europe which is in the same boat. Between these two parts of the World, there is a clear and stated goal to reduce their emissions by amounts which are multiples of the 5% over the medium term.
Not all of this reduction will come about through physical abatement programmes and a lot of the reductions will give rise to the creation of many millions of tonnes of carbon credits.

In 2005 the carbon market had an estimated value of 4 billion Euros, and by the end of 2007 that value had grown to 12 billion Euros – and this is only the Kyoto based Clean Development Mechanism and the number does not include the other emission trading systems that are active.

This is clearly not a passing fad.

From a South African perspective, and indeed the African perspective, we are seen as a source of carbon credits for the buyers. Effectively by improving our own environment and by polluting less we can earn money…not for jam, but for giving ourselves clean air. Eskom is the fourth largest utility in the World and 92% of our energy is derived from burning coal. For every tonne of coal burned, we emit almost three tonnes of CO2e. If a plant reduces their energy usage, it results in Eskom having to burn less coal and you guessed it, reduces the amount of CO2 that is put into the atmosphere. In this example if the company that owned the plant, could prove that it had effectively reduced the amount of electricity it was using, and as a consequence the carbon emissions, they would own the carbon credits that the reduction in electricity usage generated.

The most positive aspect of generating a carbon credit, which is the generation of added income to a project is also the aspect which leads to a negative aspects of carbon emission trading, and that is the perception that carbon trading is some kind of financial alchemy, and secondly that it is not going to add a material benefit in terms of cost/benefit analysis. This perception that has filtered down from CFO’s and CEO’s who feel that this instrument is below them and that it is an “environmental issue” are somewhat mistaken. It is a financial instrument that has an engineering pedigree and then an environmental outcome. First and foremost it is a financial instrument, and accordingly should be treated with the same respect that any other financial instrument is treated. If the senior executives ignore it, it is going to do what all good derivatives do…and bite hard.

Carbon emissions reduction and the ensuing carbon credit trading must becomes part of a CFO’s and the CEO’s box of tools for financing projects. We have seen the effects of senior and executive management not wanting to deal with a derivative on numerous occasions. We don’t even have to mention the names of those companies who did not pay attention to the derivative instruments that their staff were trading to know that if a derivative is left to inexperienced individuals with no oversight from executives, there is a huge potential liability that can be incurred. In South Africa, this derivative has been left to the project managers and middle managers to control. Would any CFO or CEO worth his or her salt leave the total decision for a multi million rand additional income stream to a project to anyone else but themselves?
Carbon credits are a low cost or even a free pass to use European money to, at best industrialise the entire nation, and at worse add a substantial amount of money to an individual project…that is paid over willingly – if the project is measurably cleaner than business as usual models.

This is a challenge that may not only result in a potential liability that will surprise some of the shareholders of a public company if it has been created incorrectly, but it also borders on questionable actions if an organisation will not use a derivative that has massive and positive impacts on their own earnings, on the project payback and on the environment.

We need to see a proactive leadership based approach and less “lets wait and see”. In the last two large scale projects that have been undertaken in South Africa, we have seen that the carbon credits alone have added enough income to have massive impacts on the ROI and the IRR of those projects. That’s not small change in anyone’s books, and the Executives in corporate South Africa should take cogniscence of this method of alternative financing, and bring it into the main stream.

In Europe, China, India and South America one of the very first financial models that were built by organisations looking to expand and to enhance efficiencies relates directly to how the carbon credits can be realised and what the added financial income would amount to. In both the USA and Australia one election is about to be won or lost with the ground swell of public sentiment lying very clearly in an environmental camp, and the other election was lost on amongst other sentiments, an environmental ticket. The very first action that the new Australian Prime Minister undertook was to ratify the Kyoto Protocol, which his predecessor had not done.

In South Africa, the Government has geared up and has spearheaded a tremendous effort to establish and staff a department that operates under the auspices of the Department of Minerals and Energy to facilitate and to ensure that quality Clean Development Mechanism based projects are brought onto the book. While it will always be the projects owners’ responsibility to identify, finance and operate these projects, the fact that the Government has created the Designated National Authority and that they have done it well, should give one pause before dismissing this instrument as flighty or not worth the time spent in putting it together.

While there are thoughts at the moment by the JSE Ltd to see if this instrument can be integrated or placed onto its trading platform, it is very clear that this route is not the financial Holy Grail that we should be looking at. Rather lets use the instrument for what it was intended to be – a very transparent and solidly built method, which if applied to a cleaner way of going about “business as usual” will add an income to that effort that will pay a financial incentive to the initiator of that cleaner way of doing things.

Albert Einstein in his wisdom stated something like the following: We cannot solve today’s problems and challenges using the same logic skills that we used to create those challenges and problems. It should be clear that the CDM is one of those instances where a lot of thought and integrity has gone into subsidising a cleaner way of doing things here in RSA. It’s a different way of doing things, and that does not automatically translate into it being something that executives should ignore – in fact because it is new and different, it should be analysed to see if there is an opportunity for inefficiencies to be traded. At this moment, these inefficiencies do exist…but as with all markets, these do disappear and the instrument will mature. We are losing out by not paying attention to this instrument.

There is no doubt that as time goes by South Africa will join common practice and will use carbon credits as part of the financial and project management cycle. Sometimes it makes sense to be amongst the fore runners across the Globe, and this is one of those times. Kyoto has a lifespan that will come to a halt on the last day of December 2012, and something else will rise to take its place. That something will have less inefficiency and will perhaps have less reward attached to certain of the current GHG priorities, and will cause many people in positions of decision making to hark back to the days when Kyoto was still in force and people could get rewarded for doing what will become a legal requirement.

About the author
Peter Oldacre is the Managing Director of Camco South Africa, which in turn is the African arm of Camco International, Ltd, a London AIM listed Carbon Asset Developer, which currently enjoys the premier position amongst its peers as being the “Best Carbon Asset Developer for 2007 and again for 2008”. Camco is also the recipient of many awards for innovative project finance, and is currently enjoying unprecedented growth in China, the USA, Europe and Africa. Peter also sits as part of the board which Governs Camco’s efforts into the rest of Africa. Peter has a degree in Science and has completed a number of finance and derivative trading industry related qualifications. Amongst others he is a member of the National Futures Association and the Commodity and Futures Trading Commission, which oversaw his time as a registered Commodity Trading Advisor in the USA. In South Africa Peter is registered as a Discretionary Investment Manger with the FSB, and although he does not actively trade, he understands the driving forces behind why businesses make the decisions that they make. Peter spent 12 years in the derivative trading sector before joining Camco in 2006 as the Managing Director for South Africa. He is a Fellow of the SA Institute for Financial Markets and is currently studying a Masters in Knowledge Management through the University of Stellenbosch.

Camco (Pty) LTD
Building 18, Woodlands Office Park, Western Service Road, Woodmead
PO Box 70 Woodlands Office Park, Woodmead 2080
TEL: 011 253 3400
FAX: 011 804 1038
Cellphone: 082 920 4984