Green shoots in an arid landscape
by Gina Schoeman

ismal economic indicators confirm that the global financial crisis has set an especially dreary scene for global economic activity in 2009. With trade figures all but keeling over, confidence in the doldrums and credit still firmly under strain, there seem to be few catalysts to rehydrate global growth in the coming quarters.

But there are some green shoots pushing through the concrete. Several factors cut through the gloom and while sizeable uncertainties remain, these could give reason to think that the recent freefall in global economic activity should reduce in intensity in the coming months.

Front-loaded weakness...

  • Firstly, there is an argument that much of the weakness was front-loaded. This is exemplified in the pattern of inventories in the current recession. The Macquarie Inventory Index shows destocking surged sharply in 4Q08, before bouncing along at very weak levels in the first weeks of this year. This suggests that much of the inventory adjustment and impact on production in the current recession could have been in late 2008 to early 2009
  • While the inventory component of the PMI manufacturing surveys for the major developed economies has continued to push deeper into contractionary territory in the first two months of this year, the rate of deterioration has nonetheless slowed. So though the level indicates that the reduction in inventories could continue to subtract from growth in 1H09, signs that this indicator is starting to stabilise, albeit at an extremely poor level, represents an important bright spot. Stability in inventories, if sustained, would lay the groundwork for firmer manufacturing production and business investment. And furthermore, given that inventories seem to have become increasingly pro-cyclical in recent decades in the major manufacturing economies such as the US and Germany, this could form the basis for a reasonably firm recovery.
  • Business surveys for the major developing economies, for example for China, also offer support for this positive second derivative. Current levels of the PMI surveys confirm manufacturing activity is still contracting sharply, however the rate of contraction in these indicators also seems to be getting slower. This signals an important inflection point for GDP growth, if sustained,
  • Some data points are emerging to support the shift in business sentiment. For example, after several consecutive months of decline, US retail sales rose in January, and Euro area retail sales were flat on the month in December. Chinese credit growth also quickened in January, and UK house prices rose slightly in the month after nearly a year of back-to-back falls.

Households show some signs of life

  • The other emerging sign of life to watch for is household consumption. Plunging consumer price inflation globally in recent months has bolstered consumers’ real disposable income, representing an important offset to sliding employment. The very low interest rate environment also helps, reducing households’ debt servicing burdens. As a result, rising real income can be expected to start supporting real consumption spending, once consumer confidence stops falling. With policy stimulus in place, an improvement can be expected as early as 1H09, particularly if the pace of job cuts starts stabilising.

  • This positive deflation effect should work to foster a recovery in production. Stronger consumption spending from 1H09 would expedite the drawdown in firms’ stocks, and induce an improvement in their output. And eventually, this could start to support an inventory build in 2H09, which would itself be positive for GDP growth. Significantly, there is a disparity between companies’ assessments of demand and production in the major monthly business surveys, with demand readings plunging much sharper than production expectations. This means that should real income gains hold up consumption, and prevent as sharp a drop in demand as companies anticipate, there could be an important turning point.

... Back-loaded policy support

  • Above any other green shoots, aggressive policy support has a particularly long stem. Despite the overwhelming weakness in global economic activity right now, stimulus offers prospect for recovery. This is the crucial factor underpinning the subtle yet positive shifts in inventories and household consumption, as the bolder the response, the greater the chances positive momentum will properly take hold.
  • The US, and also the UK, offer important examples that policy does work. Both economies are pushing through forceful monetary and fiscal expansion, and have also made attempt at comprehensive reform of the banking system. Against these efforts, there have been some important improvements. For example, US personal consumption growth actually rose in January. Yields on US corporate bonds have edged lower, and issuance has improved appreciably. Furthermore, the Federal Reserve’s January Senior Loan Officer Survey shows that fewer US banks tightened lending standards over the past few months compared to the October survey, which suggests that the squeeze on credit, may have reached a peak.
  • In the UK, household consumption has also proven remarkably resilient to rising unemployment, falling wealth, and a housing shock. With the Bank of England drawing closer to putting its own quantitative easing into action, and the second round of the bank rescue package underway, lending should start to track a similar trend to the US. Notably, mortgage approvals have recently steadied, albeit at an extremely low level, and with nationalised lender Northern Rock ready to offer an additional £14 billion in mortgage funding under the package, this should curb the rate deterioration in the housing market.
  • Massive fiscal stimulus, monetary easing and a scheme to fix the financial system are an undoubtedly potent combination. It is true that fiscal support and financial rescue measures have proven less timely than hoped in the US, and UK policymakers were tardy in their response to the crisis, suggesting a weak near-term outlook. However, this three-pronged policy approach should inevitably gain traction over economic activity, pointing to the prospect of recovery from late 2009. The approach also seems set to become increasingly widespread in the coming quarters, with interest rates dropping closer and closer to the floor and the capacity of conventional policy exhausted. For example, Canada is now reportedly considering quantitative easing.
  • Currency is also an important mechanism to support economic recovery. Japan offers an example of its powerful impact, with industrial production and capital expenditure collapsing. Plunging export demand is the driving force, and highlights the pass-the-parcel effect of currency shifts in transmitting what was originally a US-centric downturn. With the Yen so strong, more production cuts undoubtedly lie ahead, for example as automakers struggle to work through sizeable inventories. This presents a hefty barrier to the economy’s external adjustment, and begs structural adjustment. On the flipside, the easing in the Renminbi has been an important means to prop up slumping external demand for China. Indeed, the Chinese manufacturing PMI steadied in February, and industrial production growth improved slightly in December. Combined with policy help to stimulate domestic demand, the power of currency to drive recovery cannot be discounted.

United States

  • The best that can be said about the US economy is that the rate of deterioration seems to have slowed. This is definitely not true in some sectors, especially construction. But the stabilisation of manufacturing surveys since late 2008, including the ISM survey, is a potential green shoot. One factor that may be starting to put a floor under US manufacturing, albeit at an extremely low level, is a slight improvement in household demand. Personal consumption spending has lifted since last November. The January level of real spending was actually higher than the 4Q average, suggesting that the impact on GDP growth from the household sector may not be quite as severe in the current quarter. Lower auto sales in February were a reminder that there are still some significant risks.

  • But perhaps the strong rise in real disposable income driven by lower oil prices is starting to exert a positive influence on consumer demand. Consumption growth has been well below income growth for some time. Plunging confidence is the main reason for this divergence and the lack of confidence could mean that the gap does not close immediately. Nevertheless, if disposable income can hold these gains it is probable that there will be at least a mild consumption response.
  • While the abysmal labour market will remain a drag on household cashflow, it is likely that this will be offset by the tax cuts that will commence in April and disposable income should get another boost. With the Fed’s new TALF program in place from late March, there will be some additional support for auto sales. The auto sector will be crucial. Even a slight rise in auto demand would have a marked impact on the economy because of the extraordinarily low level of domestic motor vehicle production in early 2009. An inventory-related swing in production would then give US manufacturing a welcome boost in the second half of 2009. But a lot will depend on US consumer confidence.

Europe

  • Several European business and consumer sentiment surveys showed some signs of stability at the beginning of this year, offering very recent suggestion that the rapid deterioration in Euro area economic activity in 4Q may have eased in early 2009. Indeed, the pace of the decline in the Euro area PMI surveys, and the European Commission’s economic sentiment indicators, has slowed from the precipitous rates of late 2008.
  • Central to these glimmers of light is the German IFO survey. Significantly, the survey’s expectations component rose for the second consecutive month in February. This sub-index is a reasonable leading indicator, and its uptick in encouraging. The headline IFO index was little-changed at 82.6, down from 83.0, with current conditions to continuing to worsen, but the downtrend has clearly levelled off since mid-4Q. So while it does not point to the end of the current downturn, its stabilisation suggests a more disastrous outcome than the early 1990s German recession is not looming.

  • Outside of the survey, the hard data continue to highlight the downside risks to activity in the coming quarters. For example, factory orders continue to contract sharply and unemployment is rising at an increasing pace. And with uncertainty continuing to grip households and firms, expectations could quickly regress if the financial crisis were to intensify. With Eastern Europe’s problems on the Euro area’s doorstep, this is an important factor to keep in mind.
  • As a result, the lag between positive leading indicators and current conditions could be particularly long, with fiscal and monetary support expected to take several months yet to filter through to real activity. However, stabilisation is an important precondition for outright improvement.

Emerging Europe

  • It is simply too early to be looking for green-shoots in emerging Europe, with many economies still in free-fall. Demand for key export industries has been decimated, whilst dependence on foreign financing, coupled with large external imbalances, is proving destabilising. Private capital inflows are expected to fall a massive 88% during 2009 and an estimated US$200bn is required to support the banking system. This is on top of the support packages the IMF has already announced for Hungary, Latvia, Serbia and the Ukraine. Yet regional policy makers have little room to move. Concerns over large currency depreciations are keeping domestic interest rate declines in check, while high government debt levels are constraining fiscal measures. Rising unemployment levels have led to the incidence of political instability and undermined support for market-oriented policies in some countries.
  • Perhaps the best that can be said for emerging Europe is that it is heterogeneous. Although the entire region has and will continue to be hit hard, some economies are showing signs of being more resilient than others. Slovakia and Slovenia are already in the Eurozone, and hence have not been hit by rising local-currency debt levels. Poland, meanwhile, is much less reliant on export demand than elsewhere in emerging Europe, and these 3 economies are still expected to maintain slightly positive growth rates in 2009, compared to a 6.3% contraction in the Baltic states. These distinctions, however, are more a matter of the severity of the recession, rather than if there is one. The best-outcome will be recovery in late 2009, while weakness in the worst-affected countries of the Baltic states, the Ukraine, and Hungary, could linger well into 2010, lagging any global recovery.

Japan

  • The economic contraction in 4Q08 was extreme and it looks as though 1Q09 will be about as bad, with an export collapse driving down industrial production. In turn, this has triggered a rapid reduction of temporary workers in manufacturing which has led to national angst over job security and a rise in the household savings rate.
  • There are signs that Japan might be close to the point of maximum pain from two perspectives. First, production cuts over the past six months have been extreme, with the aim of reducing excess inventories. It looks like this process will have largely run its course by the end of 1Q09, when the level of production will bounce to a level in line with underlying demand. This still implies low capacity utilisation rates and poor corporate profitability, but not as depressed as in 1Q09. As shown in Figure 7, the automobile sector is a good example, with output running far below sales, and the individual companies are reporting inventory reduction.
  • Second, there are signs that policy neglect has reached an inflection point, with the survival instincts of a government in an election year pushing them towards more aggressive fiscal stimulus. The political weakness of the government means there will be some doubts over implementation, but at least the inaction of recent months is fading. We do not expect a radical approach from the BOJ, which seems surprisingly tolerant of the prospect of another lengthy period of deflation.

Asia ex. Japan

  • Asia finds its economies at a crossroads in the current downturn. For the region’s export driven growth model, there are signs of hope in US and EU retail sales as 2009 starts. Stabilisation in global consumer demand is critical in containing the aggressive corporate sector adjustment of the past few months as reflected in job shedding, destocking and reductions in capital spending. Unfortunately, from our vantage point, the recovery in US and EU consumption is unlikely to gather momentum given the sharp drop in the net wealth of households, rising savings rates and insufficient fiscal responses to date.
  • Our ‘Asia must save Asia’ mantra of the past several months is even more critical given the uncertainty about the sustainability of global demand. The good news is that Asian policymakers are quickly reassessing the potential severity of the current global recession and its impact on the region’s economic prospects. Hong Kong and Malaysia have announced that they will reinforce previous fiscal stimulus packages to boost growth. Singapore’s Mentor Minister Lee suggested that economic output could fall by 10% this year.
  • Further policy ease cannot come too soon. While the data points outside of China remain weak, the leading indicators of economic growth and consumer expectations have stabilised, and in some cases such as Indonesia, bounced (Figures 8 and 9). We continue to expect interest rate cuts to get better traction in ASEAN ex Singapore and India, where the cost of capital, and its availability, are of more an issue for their supply constrained economies than in North Asia where the lack of external demand is the issue. Moreover, household debt levels are already very high and capital spending tracks the global trade cycle.
  • Asia’s strong macro balance sheet, which we have highlighted in previous pieces (ample foreign exchange reserves and low net debt (public and private) levels among others), provide policy makers the flexibility to further reduce interest rates and boost fiscal spending. But more fundamental changes will be needed to rebalance Asia’s growth drivers toward domestic sources of growth. This will involve aggressive infrastructure spending, the adjustment of tax structures and the deepening of social safety nets. Given the absence of such adjustments, Asia’s potential growth rates will shift sharply downward given what we expect will be protracted slowdown in the OECD.

China

  • There are signs of two divergent trends in China’s economy. Exports have finally and spectacularly succumbed to the global crisis, falling almost 30%YoY in February. This result is even worse than it looks, because Chinese New Year fell in February 2008, meaning sales last month should have benefited from an increase in the number of working days. Coincident indicators meanwhile suggest a material recovery in domestic demand, with the PMI reaching 49 in February, up strongly from 38.8 in November last year, and just shy of the 50 needed to show expansion.
  • In the short term, the economy is likely to lose momentum. With a high base in March last year, China’s export performance is likely to be even worse this month than February’s shocking figure. As for the domestic recovery, with few of the hyped infrastructure projects yet underway and real estate construction still contracting, there hasn’t been much sign of final demand. Instead, it looks like a restocking cycle that has already come to an end, with steel prices coming off again in recent weeks.
  • The restocking cycle was only made possible by a big rise in working capital, as the banks stepped up financial support for the economy. Indeed, bank lending has been as strong as exports have been weak, with credit growth likely now near 25%YoY, the fastest since the 1990s. By stabilising the domestic economy this surge in bank lending is leading to some mobilisation of savings, suggested by rising liquidity preference, China having one of the few global stock markets to have risen this year, and a firming of property transactions.
  • Certainly, the export numbers are worse than we expected, and mean downwards risk for our 6.4% 1Q09 GDP forecast. Still, we already had a negative 2ppt contribution to GDP from net exports built into our numbers for 2009 as a whole. At the same time, the monetary trends are more powerful latter than we had forecast, which should lend more support to the recovery we were looking for in 2H09.

South Africa

  • Economic growth in South Africa peaked in 2006 at an average rate of 5.3% YoY, and has been slowing ever since (averaging 5.1% YoY in 2007, 3.0% YoY in 2008). In this way, South Africa looks relatively better-positioned than other economies facing the sharp deterioration in economic growth levels given the global financial crisis. Thanks to a steady slowdown in growth over the past 18 months, the adjustment to global recessionary conditions is more gradual for South Africa’s economy.
  • Still, official data releases in February have confirmed that the South African economy will not escape unscathed. First up, manufacturing production for December contracted massively, leading to a worse-than-expected contraction in GDP growth of 1.4% QoQ in 4Q08 . Even though this left growth averaging a relatively healthy 3.0% YoY for the year, prospects for 2009 growth worsened and we now expect growth to contract by around 0.4% YoY in 2009. Thirdly, credit growth is slowing rapidly after reaching highs of 22.0% YoY in 2008; this confirms our suspicion that SA banks are aggressively pulling back on lending. And lastly, export growth is in trouble after falling off a cliff in January (contracting by a massive 23% MoM).Even with a pick up in February, exports will suffer in 2009 which leaves the outlook for domestic manufacturing production very dismal.

  • Nonetheless, there are still some bright spots for the local economy. Firstly, the government is doing its share, expanding the 2009/10 budget deficit to 4% of GDP from virtually flat levels. Secondly, after much speculation, the SA Reserve Bank stepped in with a more frequent MPC meeting schedule and are expected to cut the repo rate by 400bps overall for 2009. Taken together, monetary and fiscal policy is most likely set to become more stimulatory than ever before and this will filter through strongly into the real economy given that the SA banking sector is relatively sound.

Australia

  • The Australian economy shrank by 0.5% in 4Q08, even though final demand spending rose in the quarter and by 2.6%YoY. In effect, businesses slashed production in anticipation of much weaker spending in 2009, with the result that inventories nosedived in 4Q. The question now is whether the current pessimism of the business community will be realised, or whether spending might prove to be surprisingly resilient.
  • To be sure, there are some sectors of the economy where it seems inevitable that demand will fall sharply. While business investment rose by 0.7% in 4Q08, we suspect that this was the last hurrah for investment, which we expect will fall sharply in 2009. Consistent with that, we think the demand for manufactured output – and exports generally – will remain weak for the next 18 months.
  • But while these are likely to be the weakest components of the economy, there are some sectors which have been improving – rather than weakening – in recent months. Retail spending is one example. This has grown in 6 of the last 7 months, with growth improving from less than 2%YoY in September 2008, up to 6%YoY in January 2009. Although this is primarily due to the Government’s fiscal injection in December 2008, with another larger stimulus coming in the March/April period it does seem likely that retail spending will be significantly stronger in 1H09 than it was in the same period a year earlier.
  • Of course, it could be argued that while the fiscal stimulus packages are providing a temporary boost to spending, retail trade could still collapse once the injections cease. However, there is another encouraging sign that is likely to prove more enduring: an improvement in the housing market. As shown in the chart below, home loan approvals have risen by more than 20% since September 2008. Importantly, this reflects increased activity by first-home buyers. Because first-home buyers represent new entrants into the housing market, they increase net demand, thereby adding some tension to house prices.

  • Evidence of this improved sentiment is also reflected in other data, such as increased foot traffic at building display home centres, and rising auction clearance rates, which have risen from 45% in mid 2008 to 70% in early 2009. If this momentum is sustained, then it is likely to result in stronger housing construction in 2H09, which will be vital to supporting current employment levels. At the very least, the persistent rise in home lending since September 2008 – and the increased activity by first-home buyers both in terms of the rising number and rising average loan value – highlights that the Australian housing market is not experiencing the same sort of credit crunch which is undermining the housing markets of some other developed markets.

New Zealand

  • While there are no signs of the green shoots of recovery in New Zealand, it doesn’t appear that New Zealand has suffered as badly as elsewhere. Though the economy has been in recession for some time, it doesn’t appear to be as severe as the contractions seen in the US, Europe or Japan. The labour market has also been surprisingly robust thus far, with the unemployment rate rising 1ppt off an extremely low base of 3½%. And despite the huge downturn in housing market activity, the falls in house prices and the impact on the banks have thus far been tame compared to that seen offshore.
  • Policy also has moved quickly and is already effective in muting the impact of the current downturn. The large fall in the currency has mitigated the impact of the crash in commodity prices, with nominal exports rising 3%YoY in January. Interest rates have also fallen a long way, providing an important boost to household incomes, with the transmission of monetary policy not impaired by a broken financial system.
  • Policy also has further scope to move. The cash rate is still relatively high, while the government has very low net debts. So while the green shoots of recovery are not yet visible, the seeds of recovery have been sown, with the economy likely to start growing again in 2H09.