Exchange Traded Funds – the key to unlock investment opportunities in and for Africa

by Nerina Visser
Head: Beta Solutions
Nedbank Capital Global Markets

 ationalisation. Colonialisation. Both are words and concepts that evoke strong emotions, regardless from which side of the debate it comes. But at the heart of the matter lies the yearning for the ownership of assets – preferably wealth-generating assets, but in particular assets to which the prospective owner has an emotional or physical attachment. The people of Africa are no different to their counterparts in other continents. For them, riches are also defined in material terms, despite attempts of psychologists and life coaches to convince us of the contrary – happiness doesn’t put bread on the table or a roof over your head. But those riches are best measured in ownership of physical assets, such as land and cattle, or resources that can grow over time and continue to provide for their families.
There are not a lot of ways to grow wealthy and, unless you are born with a silver spoon in your mouth, or are one of the few wildly successful entrepreneurs worldwide, one needs to accumulate ownership of wealth-generating assets. For most people, this can only come from a well-constructed, diversified and consistent investment strategy. This process is dependent on two equally important parts – you need to have money available to invest, and you need access to assets in which you can invest. Most people have the ability to work and, in some way, earn a living. In a well-constructed economy, at least part of those earnings will be available in monetary terms and depending on the balance of income and expenses, an individual may be in a position to have the means available to invest.
Access to investment products, however, is not that readily available. It is a well-documented fact that equities, as an aggregate asset class, over the long-term and on average, will outperform all other major asset classes such as bonds, property and cash. Contrary to popular belief, this is not only because of “compensation” for risk taken on, but rather because of the ability of equity investments to generate wealth, or growth in assets, typically linked to growth in the economy. One of the surest ways for investors to share in this is through direct participation in the growth in wealth through ownership of equities. Unfortunately, for many individuals, this is a bridge too far, as investment in the equity market must be channelled through investment professionals such as brokers, or through a pooled mechanism such as unit trusts or mutual funds. Indirect ownership is also achieved through the investments of pension funds and other insurance products but with little direct and immediate benefit to the individual.
Another impediment to investment participation at the individual level is the amount of money required to buy a “piece of the action”. Most individuals do not have the means to invest in markets on either a regular basis or to ensure a well-diversified investment exposure, as the minimum amount required to do this is too onerous. Unit trusts, or collective investment schemes, were introduced to bridge this gap and provide a vehicle for any number of investors to participate in the wealth-generating process. However, this facilitation comes at a high cost to investors – critics of the unit trust industry are quick to point out the high fees associated with investments of this nature, which over the long-term have mostly served to enrich the fund management industry, at the expense of the end-investors.
Exchange traded funds (ETFs) are a special form of unit trust, or collective investment scheme (CIS). They are governed by the same laws (CISCA) and regulations as other CISs, but because they are listed on stock exchanges, they have an additional level of regulatory oversight – the stock exchange itself. The most important benefits of ETFs are encapsulated in the acronym “TLC”: transparency, liquidity and cost control. ETFs are significantly cheaper than unit trusts and cut costs by doing away with specialists that actively manage funds. Instead, they use various indices, such as broad market, sector-specific or regional indices, amongst others, as the basis for their investment. The constituents of these indices and the rules that govern their construction are known (unlike the investment decisions driving active management); this makes them completely transparent. ETFs can also trade throughout the trading day, and a market-maker guarantees liquidity at the fair value. Investors want to know what they’re paying for and are increasingly moving towards fee-based models that reward financial planners for their advice. They want to implement this advice through the cheapest and most transparent solutions, rather than through highly-priced and complex products.
But what does this mean for investment in Africa and in particular, for investors within Africa? Thoughts of Africa conjure many images in one’s mind, not all of them necessarily positive. But mention the continent in the same breath as gold, platinum, diamonds and even oil, and a very different association is created. For centuries, the “dark continent” has represented a destination for those seeking their fortunes, some doing so using less than honourable methods. The colonisation of Africa is an emotive topic and, to this day, causes strife between some of the former colonies and their erstwhile masters. Add slavery and the exploitation of labour to the debate, and it becomes patently clear that any number of Africans still fervently believe that the continent was plundered by colonisers, with little benefit accruing to the people of Africa. To add insult to injury, there is a modern-day version of plundering that continues, albeit in a less obvious form.
Mining and exploration is a capital-intensive industry and one that requires highly-skilled resources, including financial and investment skills to assess the risks associated with particular projects and the industry in general. The JSE Securities Exchange has a long history associated with mining, as it was, in fact, founded on gold mining companies and traces its roots back to Barberton and the early days of the gold rush. To this day, the equity market in South Africa continues to be dominated by a few mining giants, such as Anglo American and BHP Billiton, and the stock exchange spends a lot of time and effort to facilitate the investment products and processes associated with the mining industry and the commodities and resources markets.
However, when one takes a further look north and scrutinises the listed companies on the stock exchanges of the rest of the African continent, you will notice that very few metals and mining, resources or commodities companies are listed. This is despite the fact that Africa is recognised as one of the richest sources of minerals, precious metals and gems in the world. In fact, one has to look much further afield to the stock markets of London, Toronto and Australia to find listings of the companies that are involved in mining operations on the African continent. The reason for this is quite simple: the complexity and capital-intensity of mining and exploration activities limit the range of financing partners available to these companies. They have to turn to the capital markets that understand mining and know how to value and assess it. The markets of London, Toronto and Australia, in addition to that of South Africa, provide both the skill and financial depth that these operations require from investors.
But unfortunately, this has resulted in a form of neo-colonialism of the continent, again to the detriment of its residents. Although the invested capital flows through to the companies and mining operations in Africa, none of the return on that capital accrues to the locals. Participation in the wealth-generation process is restricted to those investors that can access the listings in foreign markets. Individual investors need to have some serious money available for investment before this is an option for them, and although institutional investors such as pension funds are allowed to invest in foreign markets, all of the spin-off benefits within the financial services industry accrue to the foreign capital market and none to the local market. This is akin to raw materials being exported from the African continent, the beneficiation of those materials being undertaken in other markets, only for the final product to be imported back to the country of origin – obviously at a much higher price! Giving investors in Africa access to the wealth generated from their own natural and human resources would amount, in a small way, to rolling back the impact of colonisation, without having to “repossess” or take back any assets from existing investment holders.
Investors in Africa do not have ready access to investments representing a large part of their own countries’ GDP, if at all. As a result, they largely miss out on the opportunity to participate in this aspect of wealth creation. It is extremely difficult to roll back this process by convincing individual companies with mining operations on the African continent to come and list their equity on African stock exchanges. In addition, many stock exchanges on the African continent are still at a relatively early stage of development, leading to elevated levels of risk, such as liquidity, settlement, custody and access to quality information. This risk applies equally to local and foreign investors in those markets.
However, one key to unlocking the access to these wealth-generating assets lies in ETFs. Nedbank Capital has compiled a series of indices of mining and commodity stocks engaged on the African continent, irrespective of the stock exchange on which they are listed. By creating ETFs on these African mining stocks and making them directly available to investors across the continent’s stock exchanges, it will provide the opportunity for the entire spectrum of investors – from pension funds to retail investors – to participate in the benefits and wealth created by Africa’s natural resources. At the same time, trading in these instruments in the local markets can go a long way to developing the stock exchanges and related financial services industries in these markets. This will broaden the investor base for the listed companies and allow a better spread of the wealth generated, without any sacrifice or penalty required from the current investors. It truly offers a win-win solution to investment in and for Africa!

|