The Growing Significance of Islamic Finance
By Ebrahim Patel

slamic Finance as a field has received steadily growing attention over the last 30 years or so. Initially, the study of Islamic Finance was restricted to the religious realm, with the promise of creating a viable faith-based finance system applicable in modern secular economies. The main point of focus for Islamic Finance theorists was the banking arena, and the concept of Islamic Banking was born. The significance of Islamic banking for the Muslim community lay in its potential to deliver them from the charging and paying of usury, which is strongly forbidden in Islam. The power of Islamic Finance to raise capital from Muslim countries, with particular focus on petro-dollars, as well as captive local markets, led to financial institutions outside of Muslim countries focusing on Islamic Finance and the development of Islamic Finance products. Indeed, the development of Islamic Finance products has dominated the Islamic Finance landscape. But, what comes after that?
The ideas inherent in Islamic finance, and the alternative techniques present in Islamic finance to achieve the goals of society cause it to be a fertile body of knowledge for innovation and new methodologies in conventional finance. Indeed, there are Islamic finance concepts that can be adapted and implemented to change the characteristics of the conventional financial system, and can find application in banking, personal finance, business capitalisation, and many others.
The development of products essentially revolved around three key areas: banking products, primarily credit products, investment products, primarily equity funds and insurance products. In light of the global financial crisis, however, it would seem that Islamic Finance has the potential to become increasingly significant for various other reasons, especially for the insights that can be gained from the underlying philosophy and different financial architecture inherent in the Islamic financial system. The architecture of the Islamic financial system is not debt-based, but rather based on partnership. This has implications for the manner in which capital is pooled and disseminated through society. Fractional reserve banking would therefore have no place in an Islamic financial system, but rather a full reserve banking system would apply. In order to earn a return on capital, it will have to be invested as equity into a business venture or fund – thus, when people merely wanted to store money and transactional capability, they would deposit it into a full reserve bank. When people wanted to earn a return, they would make an equity investment. Thus, they would know exactly the risk that they were undertaking. This can be contrasted to the current conventional banking system, where the objectives of safe keeping and earning a return are intertwined in a fractional reserve system, and the risk assumed is not entirely clear. Even when one deposits money into a transaction or no interest account, they are assuming credit risk and liquidity risk, when all that was wanted was a means of storing money and effecting payments. Perhaps in light of the global credit crisis, there can be a two tiered banking system – one geared for risk and reward, the other purely for transactions and safe keeping – certainly, Islamic Finance can offer important principles pertaining to separation and awareness of risk.
The concept of profit and loss sharing (“PLS”) can also find expression in the conventional financial system. In a global financial system rocked by the liquidity crisis and losses of deposits, the concept of depositors sharing in losses in a “lending” bank may add stability to a fractional reserve banking system. This would work well in conjunction with a parallel full reserve banking system. The restriction on trading in intangible assets in Islamic finance may find increased application in a financial world reeling from the trading of debt obligations and various derivative instruments going wrong.
In terms of personal finance, the over-indebtedness of consumers is a topic of concern and is further underscored by the introduction of legislation to control the granting of credit to consumers. In terms of Islamic finance principles, the abhorrence of debt and the focus on living well within one’s means and becoming more productive in order to consume more (rather than merely borrowing out of anticipated future earnings)could go a long way towards increasing the net savings rate of households and increasing productivity in the economy. In terms of the capital structure of businesses, the use of equity instruments to sculpt different return profiles provides the effect of leverage without the obligations of debt. Thus, in times of economic instability, the principles of Islamic finance can be applied to achieve leverage through the use of equity only, thus enabling the enterprise to have a higher survival threshold due to the absence of debt repayments.
There are many more potential applications for the principles of Islamic finance in the modern economy, and these can be infused into existing frameworks to solve contemporary problems in modern finance or to create new products and structures. The challenge facing innovators in finance is to understand Islamic finance well enough to adapt and borrow its techniques and apply them in a secular framework. As financiers look for new and innovative ways to cater for financial needs, it is more and more likely that Islamic finance will grow in significance – not so much as a tool for tapping new markets, but rather as a body of knowledge from which new methods and techniques can be adapted.
|