Financial services providers: Conflicts of interests
by Karin van Wyk
CE0
SAIFM

 he basic principle in South African common law is that a principal (the client) is entitled to the benefit of the care and skill, which the agent (financial services provider) undertook to exercise on his or her behalf. This right may be waived wholly or partially, but it must be done freely after all material facts have been disclosed to the client. The agent must account to the principal not only for a profit made or reward received, but also for any savings made. It is not necessary that loss or harm or damage be proved on the part of the principal. A secret profit may also not be made by using information obtained for the performance of the duties under the agreement or otherwise obtained during the course of the agreement.
Should these requirements not be met, the principal may claim any profits from the agent and terminate the relationship. An agent may also forfeit his or her commission in connection with the transactions where he or she acted improperly.
All significant financial markets recognise conflicts of interest as a source of potential detriment to investors. These markets usually have rules aiming to eliminate or control conflicts to ensure investor protection and confidence. Acting as an authorised user or financial services provider (like an investment manager) when there is an incentive other than client reward represents such a conflict, unless this reward is fully disclosed and consented to by the client.
The FSP or its representative must avoid and where this is not possible, mitigate any conflict of interest between an FSP or representative and the client.(i)
A conflict of interest refers to any situation in which an FSP or representative has an actual or potential interest that may influence the objective performance of his or her obligations to the client or prevent the FSP or representative from rendering an unbiased and fair service to that client or from acting in the interests of the client. The interest may include but not be limited to a financial interest, an ownership interest and any relationship with a third party.(ii)
The General Code of Conduct defines financial interest as any cash, cash equivalent, voucher, gift, service, advantage, benefit, discount, domestic or foreign travel, hospitality, accommodation, sponsorship, other incentive or valuable consideration, excluding an ownership interest and training that is not exclusively available to a selected group of FSPs or representatives on products and related legal matters, general financial and industry information or third party specialised technological systems necessary for rendering the financial service. Travel and accommodation associated with the training are excluded.(iii)
An ownership interest is defined as any equity or proprietary interest, for which the owners paid fair value (as defined in the financial reporting standards adopted under the Companies Act) at the time of acquisition, excluding equity or a proprietary interest held as an approved nominee on behalf of another person. An ownership interest also includes any dividend, profit share or similar benefit derived from that equity or proprietary interest.(iv)
A third party includes a product supplier, another FSP, an associate (as defined below) of a product supplier or an FSP, a distribution channel (as defined below) and any person who in terms of an agreement or arrangement with any of the aforementioned provides a financial interest to an FSP or representative.(v)
An associate includes with regard to a natural person a spouse, life or civil union partner, a child, step child, adopted child or illegitimate child, a parent or stepparent, a trustee of that person, the spouse, life or civil union of any of the above persons or a commercial partner. With regard to a juristic person, in the case of a company, it includes a subsidiary or holding company of that company, any other subsidiary of that holding company and any other company of which that holding company is a subsidiary. It also includes a member of a close corporation. In the case where the juristic person is not a company or close corporation, another juristic person that would have been a subsidiary or holding company if the juristic person was a company. With regard to any person, any juristic person of which the board of directors or if applicable, the governing body is accustomed to act on the instructions of that person and includes a trust controlled or administered by that person).(vi)
A distribution channel means any arrangement between a product supplier or any of its associates and one or more FSPs or any of its associates in terms of which any support or service is provided to the FSP or FSPs in rendering a service to the client. It also includes an arrangement between two or more FSPs or any of their associates, or an arrangement between two or more product suppliers or any of their associates, which facilitates, supports or enhances a relationship between the FSP or FSPs and a product supplier.(vii)
(i) Financial interest that may be received or paid
An FSP or its representatives may only receive from or offer to a third party the following financial interests:
- commission or fees in terms of the Long-term Insurance Act, 1998, Short-term Insurance Act, 1998 or the Medical Schemes Act, 1998 , provided the fees are reasonably commensurate with the service rendered;
- If no fees or commission are paid in terms of the above acts, such fees as are agreed by the client in writing and which may be terminated by the client.
- fees or remuneration for the rendering of a service to a third party that are reasonably commensurate to the service rendered;
- an immaterial financial interest (as defined below); and
- any other financial interest, for which a consideration , fair value or remuneration that is reasonably commensurate to the value of this financial interest, is paid by that FSP or representative at the time of receipt thereof.(viii)
An immaterial financial interest refers to a financial interest that does not exceed R1000 in a calendar year from the same third party received by an FSP that is a sole proprietor, a representative for his or her direct benefit or an FSP that aggregates immaterial financial interest paid to its representatives from its benefit or some or all its representatives.(ix)
This provision does not apply where the product supplier and FSP is the same company or legal entity.(x)
An FSP may not offer any financial interest to a representative of that FSP for giving preference to the quantity of business secured for that representative without having regard to the quality of the service rendered to clients; or giving preference to a specific product supplier, where a representative may recommend more than one product supplier to a client; or giving preference to a specific product of a product supplier, where a representative may recommend more than one product of that product supplier to a client.(xi) Where the product supplier and FSP is the same company or legal entity, this provision applies in respect of the representatives of that entity.(xii)
(ii) Conflict of Interest Management Policy
Every FSP, other than a representative, must adopt, maintain and implement a conflict of interest management policy that complies with the provisions of the Act.(xiii) A conflict of interest management policy must provide for the following:
- The management of conflicts of interest and mechanisms for the identification of conflicts of interest and measures for the avoidance of conflicts of interest must be spelled out. Where avoidance of a conflict of interest is not possible , the reasons why and the measures to be taken for the mitigation thereof must be stated;
- Measures for the disclosure of conflicts of interest and processes, procedures and internal controls to facilitate compliance with the policy must be stated as well as the consequences of non-compliance with the policy by the FSP’s employees and representatives;
- The policy must specify the type of and the basis on which a representative will qualify for a financial interest by the FSP and motivate how that financial interest does not amount to a prohibited financial interest.
- The policy must include a list of all the FSP’s associates, the names of any third parties in which the FSP hold an ownership interest, the names of any third parties that holds an ownership interest in the FSP and the nature and extent of the ownership interest.
- The policy must be drafted in an easily comprehensible form and manner.(xiv)
A conflict of interest management policy must be adopted by the sole proprietor of an FSP or the board of directors or other governing body of an FSP. An FSP must ensure that its employees, representatives and associates, if any, are aware of the contents of its conflict of interest management policy and provide for appropriate training and educational material in this regard. An FSP must continuously monitor compliance with its conflict of interest management policy and annually conduct a review of the policy. An FSP must publish its conflict of interest management policy in appropriate media and ensure that it is easily accessible for public inspection at all reasonable times.(xv)
An FSP or representative may not avoid, limit or circumvent compliance with the financial interest and conflict of management policies or attempt to do so through an associate or an arrangement involving an associate.(xvi)
A compliance officer or, where the FSP is not required in terms of the Act to have a compliance officer, the FSP must include a report on the FSP’s conflict of interest management policy in compliance reports submitted to the Registrar addressing as a minimum the implementation, monitoring and compliance with and the accessibility of the policy.(xvii)
(iii) Disclosure Requirements with regard to Conflicts of Interest
An FSP or representative must, in writing, at the earliest opportunity disclose to a client any conflict of interest with regard to that client including the measures taken, in terms of its conflict of interest management policy, to avoid or mitigate that conflict. Any ownership or financial interest (excluding immaterial financial interest) that the FSP or representative may become eligible for, must be disclosed. The nature of any relationship or arrangements with a third part giving rise to a conflict of interest, must be disclosed in sufficient detail to enable the client to understand the exact nature of the relationship or arrangement and the conflict of interest. The FSP or representative must also inform the client of the conflict of management policy and how to access it.(xviii)
(i)Sec 3(1)(b) and (c), General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(ii)Sec 1 Definition of conflict of interest, General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(iii)Sec 1 Definition of financial interest, General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(iv)Sec 1 Definition of ownership interest, General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(v)Sec 1 Definition of ownership interest, General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(vi)Sec 1 Definition of ownership interest, General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(vii)Sec 1 Definition of ownership interest, General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(viii)Sec 3A(1) (a) of General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(ix)Sec 1 Definition of ownership interest, General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(x)Sec 3A(1)(c) of General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(xi)Sec 3A(1)(b) of General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(xii)Sec 3A(1)(c) of General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(xiii)Sec 3A(2)(a) of General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(xiv)Sec 3A(2)(b) of General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(xv)Sec 3A(2)(c) to (f) of General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
(xvi)
Sec 3A(3) of General Code of Conduct as amended by BN 58 of 2010 published on 19 April 2010
|