 |
|
| |
Equity Hedge – Zero cost collar
By Adam Reeves
Templewood Consulting

Summary
- Protect the value of an individual share holding
- Retain participation in growth of share value up to a cap
- No premium payable (Zero Cost)
- Protection level set to suit client’s risk appetite
Collateralised loans available on share plus collar structure. |
| Introduction |
Hedging using options can change the risk characteristics of share holdings
A Zero Cost Collar offers protection against negative price movements below a set level by capping growth above a certain level
Dividends and voting rights can be kept
No change in beneficial ownership over hedge term
Shares need to be pledged to the counterparty bank |
hen a client is holding a share for a particular time, their price expectations can be different from their original investment objectives. The client could just sell the share if they expect the price to fall, but what happens if they still want exposure to the company or it may not be the most suitable time to sell from a tax point of view? Utilising hedging strategies can alter the risk characteristics of a share holding without disposal.
How does the Zero Cost Collar work?
-
A Zero Cost Collar is a hedge strategy using options to set a protection level on share values whilst simultaneously placing a cap on the potential positive returns on the share above a set level.
-
This allows some element of upside market participation whilst protecting against drops in the share price.
-
Shares pledged as collateral at hedge bank.
-
Client remains beneficial owner of the share over the hedge term.
-
Protection is purchased by the sale of upside participation above a capped level resulting in no premiums paid or received- at ”Zero Cost”.
-
Collar options can be physically or cash settled upon election
What about my dividends and voting rights?
- Dividends & voting rights can be kept by the client
Shares are pledged as collateral at an account with the hedge bank
- Dividends and voting rights can be ceded to the hedge bank
Shares are loaned to the hedge bank
|
How does dividend choice affect pricing?
-
Collateral – shares are pledged as collateral with an account at the counterparty bank. The client will continue to be the beneficial owner. Pricing will be affected as the counterparty bank will have to borrow additional shares from the market to offset its obligation on the hedge structure. This will result in a lower cap level.
-
Loan – shares are lent to the counterparty bank with no lending fees. In return, the pricing will be more attractive as the bank does not have additional costs in offsetting its hedge obligations. This will result in a higher cap level.
-
A dividend protection agreement can be introduced which covers each party should the actual dividend declared be different from the expected dividend. The protection level and call level will be adjusted accordingly to accommodate these differences (either higher or lower than expected).
Which counterparty bank will be used?
A top 5 South African bank or an international bank with acceptable credit rating. The client will be informed before any trade and has the right to use an alternative counterparty (pricing could be affected).
|
|
The cost of protection is funded by the sale of upside participation above a certain level
Cap level is calculated for desired protection level
OR
Protection level is calculated for desired cap level
With protection, there is a minimum known future value of the share plus collar strategy
Directors or any other interested party must get clearance to trade in company sharesNo trades may take place during a closed period for any employee of a listed company
All interested party transactions (hedging included) must be report via SENS (Templates of announcements are available) |
Example of a Zero Cost Collar
A client wishes to protect a share at 90% of the current share price for a term of 18 months. The share price is currently R100.
- Current share price: R100.00
- Protection level: 90%
- Protection Price: R90.00
- Cap on growth level: 120%
- Cap on Growth price: R120
|
Cost of Protection per share R12.00
Less amount received on selling upside (R12.00)
Net cost R0.00
|

The graph shows the price performance profile of an outright share and an 18 month share plus Zero Cost Collar hedge strategy at expiry. Dividends have not been included in the payoff. The investment is now protected below the R90 level and the client will not participate in any growth above the R120 level.
Prohibited periods and director dealings
A director and company secretary of a listed company or a director of a major subsidiary company or any associates or independent entities that may derive beneficial interest now or in the future (interested party) may not deal in any securities relating to the listed company without first receiving clearance from the chairperson or other designated director.
A director must not be given clearance to deal during a prohibited period. A prohibited period includes:
- Date from financial year end and half year end up to earliest publication of financial reports for that period
- Any period where a listed company is trading under a cautionary announcement.
If a director trades in securities of the listed company, he is required to disclose to the company designate no later than 24 hours after dealing the full details of the transaction (including direct share dealing and hedge strategies implemented and the expiry of hedge transactions). The company must in turn announce such information within 24 hours after receipt of such information from the director concerned via the JSE SENS (Stock Exchange News Service). Examples of all relevant SENS announcements are available upon request.
|
If share price at expiry is below protection level, the counterparty bank needs to compensate the client the difference
No action is necessary if the share price at expiry is between protection level and cap
If the share price at expiry is above the cap level, the client needs to compensate the counterparty bank the difference
The holding period of the share needs to be considered before electing cash or physical settlement
A fixed cash amount can be advanced to the client that is repaid with interest at the expiry of the hedge term |
What Happens at Expiry?
Share price is below the protection level
- Counterparty bank needs to compensate client:
- Cash settled – bank owes client % amount below protection level.
- Physically settled – client sells shares at protection level.
Share price is between the protection and the cap levels
- No payments between parties or share movements.
Share price is above the cap level
- Client needs to compensate counterparty bank % amount above cap level:
- Cash Settled - Client pays amount or instructs bank to sell enough shares to cover the obligation.
- Physically settled – Bank buys shares from client at cap level.
Hedge transaction can be rolled for another term
Other issues to consider
How long has the share been held?
- 3 years or more –any gain on disposal treated as capital in nature
- Less than 3 years – gains may be treated as revenue in nature
Is the protection level more important than the cap level?
-
Rather than the protection level being set and solving for the cap level, a realistic cap level can be predetermined and the protection level calculated
Collateralised Loan
The client is paid a fixed collateral amount in cash as cover for the shares loaned to the counterparty bank. The cash amount will be equal to the present value of the protected value of the share holding. Interest is charged on the amount and is capitalised and only due at the expiry of the loan. The interest rate will be a wholesale rate linked to prime less a fixed spread.
- Example: R100 share protected at 90% for 18 months. Interest rate is 10% loan amount will be 78.0106%. Amount due at expiry will be R90
- At expiry, the loan can be repaid, or enough shares can be sold to repay the outstanding amount and any residual shares will be returned to the client, or the hedge and loan can be rolled for a further term.
|
Trade procedure
-
Client opens stock account with counterparty bank
-
Securities lending agreements (collateral/loan) and additional trade documentation to be signed before transaction
-
Shares transferred to counterparty bank account
-
Client enters into Zero Cost Collar
-
Protection level and cap on growth levels set by counterparty bank
-
Confirmation of hedge transaction issued to client by counterparty bank
What shares can be hedged?
- Ordinary shares (fully vested)
- Suitable liquidity in the share (usually in Top 50 shares on JSE by market capitalisation)
- Term between 6 months and 3 years
- Minimal notional value to be set by hedge bank (±R5m)
Disclaimer
As the taxation profile of each client is different, it is advised that each client should seek independent tax advice. Tax on any gains is dependant both on the nature of the taxpayer and their intention.
Past performance is not a guarantee of future performance.
|
|
EXAMPLE
ABC - ABC Limited - Dealing in securities by directors
ABC
ABC – ABC Limited - Dealing in securities by directors
ABC Limited
(Incorporated in the Republic of South Africa)
(Registration number 2000/123456/01)
Share code: ABC
ISIN: ZAE012345678
DEALING IN SECURITIES BY DIRECTORS
In compliance with the JSE Listing Requirements, the following information is disclosed:
Name of director: Mr. X
Date of transaction: 1 May 2011
Put strike: R90.00 per share
Call strike: R120.00 per share
Class of security: Ordinary shares
Number securities: 100 000
Nature of transaction: Zero Cost Collar with an expiry date of 1 November 2012
Extent of interest: Indirect beneficial
Clearance to deal obtained: Yes
Sponsor: Bank
1 May 2010
Date: 01/05/2011 11:00:00 Produced by the JSE SENS Department.
The SENS service is an information dissemination service administered by the JSE Limited (“JSE”). The JSE does not, whether expressly, tacitly or implicitly, represent, warrant or in any way guarantee the truth, accuracy or completeness of the information published on SENS. The JSE, their officers, employees and agents accept no liability for (or in respect of) any direct, indirect, incidental or consequential loss or damage of any kind or nature, howsoever arising, from the use of SENS or the use of, or reliance on, information disseminated through SENS. |
EXAMPLE
ABC - ABC Limited - Dealing in securities by directors
ABC
ABC – ABC Limited - Dealing in securities by directors
ABC Limited
(Incorporated in the Republic of South Africa)
(Registration number 2000/123456/01)
Share code: ABC
ISIN: ZAE012345678
DEALINGS IN SECURITIES
Shareholders are referred to the announcement dated 1 May 2011 in which it was disclosed that Mr. X an ABC Limited director had entered into a zero cost collar hedge over 100 000 ABC Limited ordinary shares.
In terms of the zero cost collar, if at the relevant expiry dates the share price was below R90.00, put options granted to Mr. X in respect of the shares would be automatically exercised without further reference to Mr. X. Accordingly the following shares in terms of put options granted under the zero cost collar were sold:
Date of transaction: Number of securities: Price per security:
1 May 2011 100 000 R90.00
Nature and extent of interest: Indirect beneficial
Clearance to deal: Under the terms of the zero cost collar the put options were exercised automatically and without reference to the director.
All options under the zero cost collar have now been exercised.
The records reflecting Mr. X's shareholding were adjusted to reflect a disposal of the above shares in the annual report for the year ended 28 February 2013 and as such there will be no further adjustment following the exercise of the put options.
1 November 2012
Date: 02/11/2012 11:00:00 Produced by the JSE SENS Department.
The SENS service is an information dissemination service administered by the JSE Limited (“JSE”). The JSE does not, whether expressly, tacitly or implicitly, represent, warrant or in any way guarantee the truth, accuracy or completeness of the information published on SENS. The JSE, their officers, employees and agents accept no liability for (or in respect of) any direct, indirect, incidental or consequential loss or damage of any kind or nature, howsoever arising, from the use of SENS or the use of, or reliance on, information disseminated through SENS. |
DISCLAIMER:
-
Factual information only - This document contains purely factual information and is not an expression of opinion or recommendation. It does not constitute financial product advice and should not be relied on as such. None of the information takes into account your personal objectives, financial situation or needs and you must determine whether the information is appropriate in terms of your particular circumstances. Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. and any of their agents and affiliates are dealing with you exclusively on the basis that you have sufficient knowledge, experience and/or professional financial, tax, legal and other advice to undertake your own assessment of the information.
-
Not complete - The material in this document is purely indicative and does not attempt to set out the full terms of the proposed transaction to which it refers, the details and structure of which may well differ from those set out here. This document also does not aim to notify you of any possible risks, direct or indirect, in undertaking such a transaction- including possible delays in repayment and loss of income and principal invested. This brief statement does not disclose all the risks and other significant aspects in connection with transactions of the type described herein, and counterparties should ensure that they fully understand and obtain professional advice in respect of the terms of the transaction, including the relevant risk factors and any legal, tax and accounting considerations applicable to them, prior to transacting.
-
Confidentiality - By reading this document, you acknowledge that the information has been provided to you at your request. The information is confidential and the recipient may not distribute it to other persons without the prior written consent of Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. This document is not for circulation or publication without the prior written consent of Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd.
-
Distribution of this information outside South Africa may be restricted by law and persons who come into possession of this document should seek advice on and observe any restrictions. Any failure to comply with restrictions may constitute a violation of applicable securities law.
-
Third party information - The material in this document has been prepared in good faith by Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. However, certain parts of this material have been obtained or are based upon information obtained from third parties that may not have been checked or verified. Except to the extent permitted by law, and only to the extent so required, Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. neither makes any warranty in relation to, nor accepts any responsibility or liability for any loss or damage suffered by any person arising out of or in relation to the material.
-
Not legally binding - No proposal put forward in this paper is intended to binding upon Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. or any of its associates at law whether by way of agreement, representation or otherwise. Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. will not be obliged to carry out any proposals or fulfil any terms mentioned herein and will not be responsible for any loss or damage caused as a result of any person relying upon statements made herein. All terms hereby proposed are subject to, among other things, obtaining the necessary internal approvals, the full legal review of this proposal and completion of due diligence to Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd.’s satisfaction and execution of the Documentation.
-
Errors and omissions - To the extent permitted by law, Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. accepts no responsibility for errors or misstatements, negligent or otherwise. The information may be based on assumptions or market conditions and may change without notice. Unless expressly stated, the information contained in this document is current as at the date of this document. To the maximum extent permitted by law, no member of Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. or any of their respective directors, employees, advisers or agents accepts any liability for any loss arising from the use of this document or its contents or otherwise arising in connection with it.
-
Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services Act (“FAIS Act”) – Templewood Consulting (Pty) Ltd. is a duly authorised financial services provider pursuant to the FAIS Act under FSP number 41200 and as such is authorised to provide advice and intermediary services in respect of the products identified in this document.
|
|
|
Copyright & Disclaimer , SAIFM. All Rights Reserved. Designed
& Developed by [
Live Q ] |
 |