Hedge
Funds In South Africa
By Mark Gilogley
Company: Peregrine Pacific Dunes Fixed Interest Hedge Fund


he
dictionary defines “hedge” as to guard against
the risk of loss and “fund” as a reserve of money
set aside for a certain purpose.
Traditionally Alfred Winslow Jones of the
US is known as the inventor of hedge funds in the late 1940s.
“Hedge fund” as a concept has become difficult
to define and often leads to industry stakeholders using characteristics
to explain them. As an investment approach flexibility allows
for investment strategies to take on both long position(s)
in anticipation of an upward moving market and short position(s)
in anticipation of downward trends, chase ‘absolute
positive returns’ as a differentiated measurement of
success, utilise borrowed money to leverage/increase investment
exposure per strategic intent and incorporate derivatives
and other non-securities investments as instruments for increased
returns.
Hedge funds to date have neither been statutorily
nor legally defined. The Managed Funds Association in the
US broadly defines a hedge fund as ‘any pooled investment
vehicle that is privately organised, administered by professional
investment managers, and not widely available to the public’.
The premise fundamentally outlines the fact that hedge funds
are known to purposefully operate outside the ambit of investment
regulations and has given much rise to the debate of why pension
funds and institutional investors are reluctant to invest
in the current form.
AIMA (Alternative Investment Management Association)
estimates that South Africa has in excess of 80 operating
hedge funds with an approximate value of over nine and a half
billion rand of assets invested. Factors contributing towards
awareness and interest by the investing public and authorities
at large are attributed to the unusually high growth rates
of the product as an investment vehicle, high rates of return,
limited control by investment regulatory bodies, undefined
risks and the low levels of knowledge about the complexities
of both the products and services. Flexibility, speed and
access as an unregulated investment have however been ascribed
as keys to the success and benefits of such investment vehicles.
South African hedge funds tend to focus on
Long/Short Equity strategies with the second most favoured
style being Fixed Interest opportunities. Industry observers
attribute such trends to regulatory limitations, exchange
control and the need for increased innovative financial instruments
i.e. derivatives. Local participants are said to be competitively
disadvantaged at the hands of international participants due
to restrictions on liquidity and diversity.
The main drawback for the industry not being
regulated, however, is that stakeholders are not permitted
to market such products to the general public. Lags in decision
making by the FSB (Financial Services Board) could be attributed
to the authorities looking to larger markets with longer track
records such as the US or Europe to lead the way in regulating
the alternative investments industry.
Capacity constraints continue to concern
leading stakeholders as the example of the Long Term Capital
Management (LTCM) fund continues to weigh heavy on the minds
of investors and regulators in that the world’s brightest
and largest fund failed to overcome the inherent potential
of systemic risk in 1998. As a lesson however, many stakeholders
have taken to limit and manage risk exposure whereby it is
believed by observers that excessive returns will begin to
even out or become more reasonable as increased capital allocations
diminish the competitive advantage of early stage participants.
Peregrine incorporates a range of models to include fixed
interest opportunities and the growing trend towards macro
models for opportunity in spreading risk and capturing the
upside in efficient diversification models.
A primary factor in the debate between traditional
fund management and hedge fund management is that hedge funds
are said to derive a competitive advantage from being small.
Speed and flexibility enable the manager to exploit situations
that larger more cumbersome funds often find difficult to
copy. Investing by hedge funds (as a characteristic of closed
funds) can take place without the risk of being noticed, which
is often a drawback for larger funds relative to capital absorption
in terms of the size of the investments.
The argument for ‘smaller equals better’
is furthered by the fundamentals that economies of scale can
negate the benefits of specific events through changes in
frequency and capacity that lead to the phenomenon of investment
bubbles i.e. too much money chasing too few opportunities.
Contenders argue that such concerns are averse to the creation
of ‘market efficiency’ e.g. strategies using derivatives
and short selling can be used by the more ‘sophisticated’
investor to hedge out inefficiencies.
The point being that hedge fund ‘returns’ according
to a London based research firm, Crossborder, are cyclical
in nature and a factor of both investment capital flows and
the relative strategies employed at the time.
Critics argue that the regulatory ‘blessing’
of the industry will result in extensive growth, especially
due to institutional interest. The effect is sure to place
additional strain on current capacity as ‘growth models’
are seen to be adding to the complications and nervousness
of envisaged diminishing returns and will, in all probability,
lead to the growth in non-traditional strategies and investment
fields.
For the investor that is keen but has little
understanding or time to review each fund and the associated
complexities, there is the increasingly popular fund of hedge
fund (FOHF) option. The approach provides the investor with
a service of sophistication wherein the strategy reduces the
typical onerous capital requirements, due diligence needed
to identify a suitable hedge fund ‘partner’ and
complication that strategies making up the industry today
may not be the same as in the past and are likely to be different
in the future. Advantages to FOHF styles include the likes
of diversification of cost and capital through economies of
scale, closer access to the industry and closed funds, access
to specialised services, due diligence analysis, risk management,
portfolio management, strategy selection, reporting and performance
analysis.
Concern, however, emanates from an increased
layer of costs, exposure to other investors cash flows and
less control over transparency, decision-making, preferred
strategies and performance.
Projecting the South African trend
Degrees of sophistication and transparency are set to become
increasingly important wherein the investor (customer) will
need to attain a level of satisfaction in terms of understanding
the decision making process and ability to scrutinise results
as a partner in being fully aware of the risk premium associated
with his/her returns.
The benefits of economies of scale as a factor
of competitive forces is sure to encourage increased integration
and institutionalisation of alternative investments into traditional
money management styles and result in the investment class
becoming an optional extra upon regulation of the industry.
Retail investors to align with the trend on the basis of attaining
opportunities associated with diversification at more affordable
costs at trusted institutions that are perceived as having
the skills and knowledge to manage investments returns. A
smaller separate class of partnerships of the more sophisticated/wealthier
investor types may however continue on the basis of speculative,
riskier and/or innovative opportunities as an inherent trait.
The middle ground for the retail investment
trend is sure to be in the advancement of Fund of Hedge Fund
(FOHF) styles wherein ‘smaller equals better’
asset management styles would be contracted by larger institutional
managers to retain both benefits of efficient diversification
and sophistication as a measure in deterring diminishing limitations
as mentioned.
Supply as a determinant of industry stakeholders
themselves will evolve to capture the interest of the investors
for a more secure and lucrative investment returns. We envisage
innovative supply i.e. passive management styles to evolve
on the back of a more developed and competitive environment
if trends continue to correlate that of developed financial
sectors.
By developing prime brokerage businesses
to incorporate administrative functions as determined to be
a global trend, prime brokers would have a financial interest
in developing a core competence as administrators in facilitating
the needs of both regulators and a self regulating environment
i.e. to be competitively advantaged by way of meeting the
sectors operational requirements in transparency to include
factors such as public disclosure, reporting frequency, sophisticated
technological systems and capabilities and customised reporting.
The prime broker to comply with the regulatory
body’s requirements wherein additional services in terms
of offering the competitive operational advantage would be
encouraged as a precept to developing the sector’s competitive
edge.
Sources and Bibliography
AIMA South Africa., Sep (2004) ‘Hedge Fund Booklet”
Gilogley, M., Jan (2005) MBA dissertation ‘An analysis
of hedge funds as influenced by the economic, operational
and regulatory environments within the current South African
investment climate’
Needham, C., Sep (2005). The Sunday Times ‘Limit your
risk in heady markets’
International custody and Fund Administration. Aug (2005)
‘Time for growth, hedge fund review’
|