Corporate
Governance and King III
By Karin van Wyk
CEO - SAIFM

 orporate
governance refers to those principles and procedures underlying
the way in which companies and other organisations should
be directed and controlled and originate from the division
of ownership and control in a company and the need to clarify
the roles and responsibilities of the board of directors and
the management of a company. The idea of good governance has
been developed to restore trust in companies after numerous
corporate failures and scandals eroded the trust of stakeholders
and societies in companies.(1)
South Africa has been at the forefront of
international development of corporate governance principles
through the various King Codes of Corporate Governance, initiatives
by The Institute of Directors in Southern Africa (IoDSA),
the latest of which is King III, published in 2009. King III
emphasises Integrated reporting that requires that, in addition
to the financial reporting, the company also reports how the
company during the past financial year impacted the economic
life of the community in which it operated, whether positively
or negatively and how the company intends in the coming year
to enhance a positive impact or to improve a negative impact.(2)
Good governance rests on four fundamental
principles, i.e. fairness, accountability, responsibility
and transparency. Fairness means that the interests of all
the stakeholders must be taken into account. The stakeholders
refer to any group affected by the company’s operations
including for example, employees, suppliers and the community
in which a company operates. Accountability refers to the
ability of a board to explain and justify its actions while
responsibility refers to the obligation of the board to take
good care of the assets, investments and interests of the
stakeholders. Transparency implies disclosure of the company’s
financial, risk, social and environmental performance.(3)
The philosophy underlying King III is concerned
with three principles:
- 1. Effective leadership characterised by the four fundamental
principles of fairness, accountability, responsibility
and transparency as well as the concept of ubuntu
(4) , , a South African concept
that includes mutual support and respect, interdependence,
unity, collective work and responsibility.
- Sustainability which implies conducting an entity’s
operations in such a manner that existing needs are met
while taking into consideration the economic life of the
community and the impact of its operations on future generations(5).A
company is expected to be a responsible citizen that must,
in an integrated manner, take the following into consideration
when formulating strategy, risk and performance: social,
environmental and economic issues. A company must therefore
not only report on sustainability, but its performance
must be sustainable.(6)
- Corporate citizenship based on the Constitution that
imposes responsibilities on individuals and corporate
entities alike to ensure that people can rely on the realisation
of fundamental rights.(7)
While some governance principles are taken up in legal requirements
such as the Companies Act and the JSE Listings requirements,
they are principles that may or may not be applicable to a
particular organisation. Since King III applies to any entity
and not only listed companies, the voluntary nature of the
Code is especially important since it is not possible to have
one set of rules that applies equally to all the variants
of corporate life. Accordingly King III follows a “apply
or explain”-approach where the board may decide not
to follow a principle in particular circumstances yet still
achieve good corporate governance. The starting point of the
board however will always be ensuring that legal requirements
are complied with. (8)
The success of the Code is dependent on
the active participation of institutional investors, the main
owners of shares in South Africa, to ensure proper implementation
thereof. Institutional investors are obligated to do this
since they are the custodians of the interests of the ultimate
beneficiaries, being members of retirement funds, policy holders
of insurance companies and other individuals whose interests
are indirectly represented by institutional investors.(9)
King III follows a stakeholder inclusive
model which posits that taking the legitimate interests of
stakeholders of the company into consideration, is also in
the best interests of the company. The supremacy of shareholder
interests is thus no longer regarded as an acceptable model.
Success is now defined in terms of the long term positive
impact on all stakeholders of a company or other entity (10).
As potential investors need to assess the economic value of
a company that includes aspects such as future earnings, brand,
goodwill, quality of management and risk management and whether
sustainability issues have been taken into consideration,
a corporate entity must provide integrated reports that will
also supply forward looking information as opposed to the
financial statements that focus only on a snapshot of the
company at a point in time. Such a report must contain sufficient
information so that a potential investor can evaluate how
the company has impacted on the economic life of the company,
whether positively or negatively. It should also indicate
how positive aspects will be improved and negative aspects
minimised. (11)
The principles expanded upon and explained
by the King Code will inevitably be applied differently by
different entities. Such an entity must report as part of
its financial reporting (i.e. in an integrated manner) how
the principles have been applied or not applied. As King III
implies continuous improvement in governance, the reports
will be dynamic and evolving. More consideration and explanation
will thus be required than formerly. Each principle is of
equal importance so that all together a holistic approach
to governance is achieved. Reporting on both financial matters
and sustainability in an integrated, holistic and transparent
manner should be done and the process supervised by the audit
committee. (12)
The principles of the Code are summarised
briefly with selected aspects being highlighted. As King III
is very comprehensive and provides extensive guidelines with
regard to the practical implementation of the principles,
it is recommended that the full Report and Code be consulted
on the website of the IoDSA at www.iodsa.co.za
:
- The board of a corporate entity should provide ethical
leadership, manage the company’s ethics effectively
and ensure that the entity is not only a responsible citizen,
but is manifestly so (13). Corporate
governance principles should be adhered to while fully
appreciating that strategy, risk, performance and sustainability
are integrated. Broadly speaking the board must always
act in the best interests of the company. (14)
- • The board should ensure that an effective and
independent audit committee exist that must conduct risk-based
internal audits. The audit committee must consist of independent
non-executive directors and the chairman may not serve
as the chairman of the Board (15).
TThe board is also responsible for compliance by the entity
with all laws and Codes and the integrity of the sustainability
report based on the principles of transparency and accountability.
(16)
- New issues that merit the board’s attention in
terms of King III include information technology governance
that should be aligned with the objectives of the board
in terms of performance and sustainability. Business rescue
provisions in case the entity has financial difficulties
that hitherto has not been adequately addressed, are highlighted
in King III as it is important to ensure that entities
that are still financially viable should be saved in the
interests of all the stakeholders.(17)
- As part of the board’s responsibility for risk
governance, the board must pre-determine the acceptable
levels of risk and monitor that risks taken are within
set parameters of acceptable risk. The audit or risk committee
should assist the board in carrying out this function.
(18)
- • Relationships with and perceptions of stakeholders
should be actively managed as an important aspect of protecting
and enhancing the reputation of the company.(19)
To ensure that it is able to fulfil the arduous
responsibilities placed on it by King III, the board should
consist of a majority of non-executive directors; while the
majority of non-executive directors should also be independent
i.e. they should not have a relationship with the company
that may cause them to be biased. The chairman must be an
independent non-executive director.(20)
King III is a world class achievement for
South Africa and provides the most modern thinking and intellectual
leadership to boards and management of all corporate entities
for a future in which failure to change and adjust may have
catastrophic consequences for the planet and generations to
come.
(1) Module 2 p3
(2) King Code of Governance for South Africa 2009, p4
(3) Module 2 p3 Code p60
(4) Code p61
(5) Code p61
(6) Code p11
(7) Code p10
(8) Code p7-8
(9)Code p9
(10) Code p12
(11) Code p13
(12) Code p19, 32, 54
(13) Code p19-20
(14)Code p23, 24
(15) Code p22, 24, 31
(16) Code p 24
(17) Code p12
(18) Code p 37
(19) Code p46
(20) Code p24-25, 52 |