Foreign
Tax Compliance Act FATCA[T]
By Anna Bouhail
Educational Head: SAIFM

Introduction
 FATCA,
the Foreign (Non-US) Account Tax Compliance Act (coined by
some in the US as FATCAT) came into effect in the United States
(US) on the 18th of March 2010 as part of the Hiring Incentives
to Restore Employment (HIRE) Act of 2010.
With the new legistlation the US is effectively
attempting to initiate a worldwide exchange of information
on US persons aimed at curbing the use of non-US entities
by US individuals to evade US taxes. The FATCA rules goes
considerably further than the current Qualified Intermediary
(QI) regulations – which will remain in place - and
will have a significant impact on the financial sector worldwide.
A key feature of the legislation is the requirement
that South African and other non-US financial insitutions
enter into an agreement with the United States Internal Revenue
service(IRS) to report information about US account holders
or face a 30% withholding tax on all payments from US sources.
Information and processes currently available at non-US financial
institutions are not sufficient to provide the IRS with the
required data, especially as the onus of accurate reporting
to the IRS lies with the financial institutions.
The new reporting requirements applicable
to South African and other non-US financial insitutions will
start from the beginning of 2013. It is essential for financial
institutions to gain a detailed understanding of the new act
to allow enough time to adapt processes and systems to the
new regulations.
What FATCA
is all about?
The provisions of FATCA are intended to promote compliance
with US law demanding US persons to report income from offshore
accounts. Although the new rules hold important implications
for individuals, FATCA is also of great importance for financial
entities throughout the world. Its provisions will substantially
affect non-US investment in the United States by and through
South African and other non-US entities. Under the new act
new reporting and disclosure requirements for non-US assets
will be phased in between 2010 to 2013.
FATCA has essentially five parts that is
summarized below. The rules are however considerably more
detailed, but the summary should however be sufficient to
demonstrate that FATCA is legislation of enormous reach and
serious depth.
Increased
disclosure of beneficial owners
Applicable
to non-US financial institutions and certain non-US
non-financial entities |
In order for non-US financial institutions
and non-US non-financial entities to have access to
US capital markets without being subjected to a 30%
withholding tax, these entities will have to provide
information to the IRS about their US accounts on an
annual basis.
FATCA also attempts to limit non-registered
obligations by repelling the interest deduction for
the issuer of bearer bonds issued to non-US persons. |
| Under
reporting with respect to non-US assets
Applicable to individual U.S. persons who hold non-US
assets |
If non-US assets are valued in excess
of $50 000 the US taxpayer must attach certain information
to their income tax returns. FATCA would impose heavy
penalties for failure to disclose such information and
penalties for underpayments due to undisclosed non-US
financial assets.
In the event of substantial omissions
of gross income derived from assets the statute of limitations
would be extended from three to six years. |
Other
disclosure provisions
Applicable to U.S. persons that are shareholders of
non-US passive investment companies |
FATCA requires US shareholders
of passive non-US investment companies to file annual
information returns with the IRS. |
Provisions
related to non-US trusts
Applicable to non-US trusts with U.S. beneficiaries
|
| The new rules make it more difficult
to avoid having a US beneficiary of a non-US trust and
states clearly that uncompensated use of trust property
is treated as a new distribution.
There is also a new reporting requirement
for US owners of non-US trusts and a new minimum penalty
of $10 000 for failure to report. |
Substitute
dividends and dividend equivalent payments |
FATCA will treat certain substitute
dividends and dividend equivalent payments under principal
contracts (such as total return equity swaps) received
by non-US persons as US source income. |
FATCA effective
dates
Different provisions of FATCA are subject to different effective
dates. The 30% US withholding tax on payments to non-US financial
institutions that do not enter into an information exchange
agreement with the IRS will be effective as from the 1st of
January 2013. However, no amount must be deducted or withheld
from any payment under any obligation outstanding on 18th
of March 2012 – referred to as grandfathered obligations.
The effective date for the new dividend equivalent
rules is payments made as from the 14th of September 2010.
All other provisions are effective for tax years beginning
after the 18th of March 2010.
On the 27th of August 2010 the IRS issued
notice 2010-60 (the “Notice”) which providing
preliminary guidance on the implementation of certain sections
of FATCA. The Notice is the fist step in the efforts of the
IRS to accelerate the publication of guidance to allow affected
persons and entities time to implement the systems and processes
necessary to comply fully with the new withholding, documentation
and reporting obligations resulting from FATCA.
How will FATCA
implement automatic exchange of information?
FATCA “invites” all non-US financial institutions
and non-US entities covered by FATCA to enter into a contract
with the IRS. With this agreement, the institutions undertake
to identify US customers and to report their assets to the
IRS on an annual basis.
Any non-US financial institution who does
not enter into an agreement with the IRS will be penalized
by a 30% withholding tax on US revenues and proceeds from
sales of instruments which yield revenues from US sources.
US revenues include:
- Dividends
- Rents
- Salaries
- Wages
- Premiums
|
- Annuities
- Compensations
- Remunerations
- Emoluments
- Other fixed or determninable gains, profits and
income
|
This consititutes the automatic exchange
of information by non-US financial institutions to the IRS.
These disclosure and reporting requirements could be in addition
to any requirements imposed under the Qualified Intermediary
(QI) program.
How will reporting
under FATCA work?
Reporting the necessary information to the IRS will require
four recurring steps, illustrated below.
-
Identification
of all US accounts
The non-US financial institutions to which FATCA apply
must identify all US accounts.
-
Obtaining
waivers from account holders
Non-US financial institutions must obtain a waiver from
each account holder, so that they can report the required
customer data to the IRS. In such cases, banking secrecy
is lifted and the exchange of information with the IRS
is approved. If a customer refuses the waiver request,
the act requires that the financial institution close
the account or abstain from entering into a new business
relationship. It is still unclear as to what happens if
the local law does not allow for unilateral termination
of the business relationship on the part of a bank.
-
Annual
reporting
By signing the contract non-US financial institutions
undertake to provide the IRS with required information
on US accounts annually in electronic format.
-
Penalisation
of uncooperative non-US financial institutions and US
account holders
A 30% withholding tax is deducted from payments to non-US
financial intermediaries that do not enter into a contract
with the IRS and to US account holders who do not sign
a waiver.
Information to be reported by non-US financial
institutions
- Name, address and US taxpayer identification number
of the account holder who is a US person
- The account number
- Account balance or value
- Receipts in the financial account (US & non-US)
- Withdrawals/payments from the financial account
|
The FATCA umbrella
US persons covered by FATCA
Non-US financial institutions must report to
the IRS information about a financial account which is a United
States account whatever the income is a US source income or
a non-US source income.
| Non-US financial institution |
Any financial institution which is a non-US entity |
| Financial institution |
Any entity that-
- accepts deposits in the ordinary course of a banking
or similar business
- is engaged in the business of holding financial
assets for the account of others
- is engaged primarily in the business of investing
or reinvesting or trading in securities
|
| Securities |
Securities for FATCA purposes include the following:
- Shares
- Interest in public traded partnerships
- Debt
- Swaps
- Most derivatives products
- Actively traded commodities
- Commodity swaps
- Derivatives referencing commodity prices
|
.
Non-US entities excluded from FATCA reporting
(notice 2010-60)
-
Holding companies that are not
investment funds and that hold only subsidiaries
that are not financial institutions
-
Start-up companies that are
intent to start non-financial institution businesses.
However this exclusion will expire after the first
24 month of the entity’s organization
-
Non-financial entities that
are liquidating or in the process of reorganizing
pursuant to bankruptcy
-
Hedging or financing entities that
service only a non-financial “expanded affiliated
group” that does not include any financial
institutions
-
Insurance companies that issue
insurance or reinsurance contracts without cash
value, such as most property and casualty insurance
companies, reinsurance companies and life insurance
companies that issue only term life insurance contracts
-
Retirement plans that qualify as
retirement plans under law, that are sponsored by
a non-US employer and do not allow US participants
other than general employees that work for the non-US
employer
Investment funds and other entities
that have only a small number of direct or indirect
account holders will be subject to less burdensome
reporting requirements for example a family trust
settled and funded by a single person for the sole
benefit of his/her children.
Financial institutions organised under
the laws of US territory will not be treated as non-US
financial institutions.
|
Type of income subject to FATCA
Both US source income and non-US income is subject
to reporting.
Non-US financial
institutions with “election” – an alternative?
FATCA offers non-US financial institutions
an alternative – instead of deducting the withholding
tax for uncooperative institutions or account holders, they
can decide that an upstream non-US financial institution shall
deduct the withholding tax. In this case, the upstream custodian
requires all information on account holders and the corresponding
payments so that the withholding tax can be deducted in advance.
This option is suitable for small financial
institutions, although it similarly calls for major adjustments
to internal processes and systems. Furthermore non-US financial
institutions with “election” are not relieved
of the heightened customer identification obligations.
Strategic and
operation challenges
FATCA represents a major challenge for South African and other
non-US financial institutions. The scope is significantly
broader than that of the current QI regime and the act cannot
be adhered to with current processes and systems.
South African financial institutions must
gain a clear understanding of how their business should look
in the coming years and how they want to position themselves
in the new environment.
Financial institutions should be asking the
following questions:
- Should US persons still belong to the clientele?
- Will US securities be included in the product portfolio?
If an institution answers these questions
with “yes”; the institution will be required it
to enter into an agreement with the IRS and to adapt its operating
model accordingly.
In the event of complete withdrawal, it is
also advisable to check whether continuation of the QI agreement
is still appropriate.
Belonging to an “expanded affiliated
group” has far-reaching consequences, because a financial
intermediary that is a part of a group of companies that includes
at least one other non-US financial institution which has
signed the agreement with the IRS is also obliged to adhere
to the requirements of FATCA. However, this financial intermediary
is free to enter into its own agreement with the IRS. In principle,
membership of an expanded affiliated group is assumed if at
least 50% of a company is controlled directly or indirectly.
In order to enable adherence to these requirements, the flow
of information between the various companies in a group must
be expanded considerably and the processes must be harmonised.
If a South African financial institution
decides to comply with FATCA and to enter into an agreement
with the IRS, it must closely examine its operating model.
The identification and documentation of customers, as well
as reporting thereon, is fundamental. The products offered
must also be assessed with regard to US source and flagged
accordingly in the systems. Anyone offering their own products
must also check the sales restrictions which apply to US persons.
The forms and procedures used to date are
inadequate for providing the IRS with the information required
by FATCA. Therefore a new set of processes and forms is required.
Finally the training of compliance officers, relationship
managers and staff is an essential task to be considered by
institutions.
In closing
In the process toward more efficient international tax cooperation,
FATCA may be a significant step toward automatic exchange
of information. It may presage the greater involvement of
financial institutions in the mechanics of automatic exchange
of information. Therefore the biggest question remains –
WILL OTHER COUNTRIES FOLLOW SUIT?
This article is only a general discussion
of FATCA. The specific facts of each particular situation
should be carefully reviewed
Works Cited
Memorandum on the U.S Non-US tax compliance act circular by
David Spencer (TaxJustice)
Mastering the challenges of the new US regulation circular by
Ernst & Young
Non-US Account Tax Compliance Act for South African financial
institutions circular by Deloitte
U.S. Internal Service Notice 2010-60
|