ABSA Investment
Overview 2005 - 2nd Quarter
By Christo Luüs - Absa
Group Economic Research
The outlook for global growth has been lowered further
since the beginning of 2005 - mostly due to international
oil prices reaching record highs during the first quarter
of 2005. However, inflationary pressures are likely to remain
fairly subdued in Euroland, with only moderate price pressure
expected in the United States. Interest rates are nevertheless
expected to rise in the USA, while bond markets continue
to look expensive in most of the major markets. The outlook
for equity markets remained mixed, with further gains possible
in Europe and Asia, and risks remaining high in the USA.

Equity market
he very high equity market returns observed during the final
quarter of 2004, made way for substantially weaker returns
during the first quarter of 2005. The average month-on-month
returns (annualised and expressed in US dollar) amounted
to -27,8% during the first quarter, but the average returns
for the latest 12-month period was still at a very acceptable
32,6%. In rand terms, the JSE all-share index also managed
a positive annualised return of 7,5% during the first quarter.
The weakening in USD-returns during the
course of 1Q2005, was mainly attributable to a weakening
in the ZAR/USD exchange rate during January and the early
part of February, while the all-share index ended March
much weaker compared with its record highs reached at the
end of February and early part of March 2005.
Market
valuations for some major indices – such as banks
and industrials – on the JSE improved marginally to
above their one-year average levels in the first quarter,
while the PE ratios for the IT and real estate sectors showed
significant increases. Valuations for the mining and resources
sectors remained fairly stable compared with their one-year
average values, while insurance declined further. During
the first quarter, the weakening equity market trend was
clearly discernable from the movement in the JSE all-share
PE ratio. From its lower turning point of just more than
13 in mid-2004, the ALSI PE ratio moved up to a high of
15,6 in February 2005, before falling back to below 14 by
end-March.
The JSE suffered some losses mainly in
sympathy with outflows that occurred in most emerging markets
during the last part of the first quarter. Investors pulled
out some USD2 billion from emerging market funds during
the last two weeks of March, although the net cumulative
selling by foreigners on the JSE was limited to some USD110
million for the period 11 March through 1 April 2005. For
the first quarter as a whole, net foreign equity purchases
on the JSE still amounted to more than USD1,5 billion.
In an international context and measured
in US dollar terms, the South African equity market performance
was also well below that of most other emerging and developed
markets in the first quarter of 2005. Emerging equity markets
registered an 8% (annualised) return, while world equity
came in at -3,9%. However, measured over longer periods,
the South African equity market performance was much higher
at 32,6% over a year and 39,4% over three years, compared
with emerging market equity returns (respectively 17% and
19,2% over one and three-year periods) and world equity
returns (respectively 11,1% and 6,9%). Over the past twelve
months, South African equity as an asset class was hard
to beat, with only South African property putting up a better
performance.

Over the next twelve months, domestic interest
rates should remain relatively stable while commodity prices
are expected to remain strong on the back of solid global
growth – especially in Asia. South Africa’s
gross domestic expenditure could rise by more than 5% in
real terms, which should have a positive effect on companies’
earnings growth rates. After a slump of more than 30% in
the earnings of resources shares for the year ended March
2005, some recovery is also expected in this sector and
a rise of around 30% in the ALSI earnings growth might be
possible for the next twelve months. This could facilitate
a total return of some 27% for equity in rand terms over
this period.
Globally, equities are once again expected
to perform better than bonds. The performance of equity
markets in various countries are nevertheless expected to
be disparate. In the US, corporate profit growth is bound
to slow fairly sharply while high valuations and a strong
possibility of higher interest rates are additional negatives
for this market. In Europe, economic growth prospects look
fairly bleak, but corporate restructuring and attractive
dividends could have a positive effect on equity returns.
Japanese growth is expected to resume, while relatively
low valuations and positive earnings growth prospects should
underpin the equity market. Most of the leading emerging
equity markets have already had a good run, but high commodity
prices, low interest rates and relatively sound economic
policies could extend the positive performance of equities.
Bond market
Bond yields have been in a bull market since mid-June 2004,
which brought yields on the benchmark R153 government stock
down from 10,25% to 7,4% by end-February 2005. However,
this trend seems to have been broken in March when yields
increased substantially, ending the first quarter at around
8,2%.
The
weakness in the South African bond market coincided with
reports that global funds were reducing their exposures
to emerging markets. In addition, bond yields reacted to
higher international oil prices and a jump in domestic fuel
prices, which ignited fears of higher domestic inflation
and the possibility of interest rate hikes. Consequently,
foreigners sold some USD0,2 billion worth of bonds during
the period mid-February to mid-March 2005. However, towards
the end of March, foreign buying interest in the SA bond
market resumed.
The annualised dollar return on South African
bonds amounted to -33,8% in the first quarter of 2005. This
compared quite unfavourably with a -4,7% on emerging market
bonds and -9,9% on world bonds. Measured over longer periods,
the structural decline in inflation over the past few years
together with sound fiscal policy management, nevertheless
contributed greatly to higher bond prices and therefore
solid returns over one year (16,7% annualised dollar terms)
and three year (44,6%) periods. These figures compare very
favourably with both emerging market bond returns (6,9%
and 15,1%) and world bond returns (5,5% and 14,5%) over
periods of one year and three years respectively.
Inflation expectations for the remainder
of 2005 – a major determinant of bond yields –
will evidently be heavily influeced by the future course
of the exchange rate, food prices, and fuel prices. The
strong rand and benign food price inflation pressure are
presumably both candidates for a shock in a negative direction,
while higher oil prices have already given rise to slightly
higher inflation expectations. However, given the view that
the US dollar will remain under pressure as well as the
possibility that oil prices will soften in coming months,
inflation pressures will most likely be contained so that
short-term interest rates are unlikely to rise in 2005.
As far as the potential impact of government finances on
bond yields is concerned, it would appear that the budgeted
deficit-to-GDP ratio of 3,1% for 2005/06 will once again
be lower, so this too could be supportive of the bond market.
Long bond yields are expected to fluctuate within the 7,5%
to 8,5% range during the next twelve months, and the rand
returns on bonds should remain substantially positive –
at around 15% – during this period.
Government
deficits have edged higher in many of the world’s
biggest economies and some inflation may start to emerge
during the course of 2005, while economic growth rates are
expected to moderate slightly. All of this would imply weakness
in global bond markets. However, it would appear that any
negative movement in bond yields will be limited, owing
to the apparent willingness of many institutional investors
to pay higher prices for high quality bonds. High levels
of debt and some risk aversion following the bursting of
the stock market bubble are some of the reasons why “fair
value” yields on bonds be somewhat lower than would
be suggested by historical real yields. Bond yields over
the next year should rise by some 50 basis points in the
USA, UK and Euroland and by somewhat more in Japan. Emerging
market bond yields are expected to remain fairly stable.
Cash
Cash was the best performing South African asset class in
the first quarter of 2005, registering -9% in annualised
dollar tems. Over a year, SA cash investments in dollar
terms remianed attractive, recording an increase of 18,6%
in dollar terms and 8,2% in rand terms.
International oil prices remain a very
important factor for domestic (and global) inflation. The
benchmark Brent crude oil price soared from just below $40/bl
in early January 2005 to more than $55/bl in March, prompting
increases in domestic fuel prices of around 10% on average
for the first four months of 2005. Although the direct impact
on inflation should not endanger the inflation target of
the SA Reserve Bank, rand weakness or higher oil prices
may prompt a much earlier interest rate increase. Other
issues which should remain of some concern to the Monetary
Policy Committee (MPC) as it conducts its meetings during
the course of 2005, include the high levels of household
consumption expenditure and credit growth; high asset price
inflation (especially property); a widening current account
deficit; rising level of household indebtedness and steep
increases in unit labour costs.
It would therefore appear that the current
domestic interest rate cycle is at or close to its lower
turning point. Technical factors will work in favour of
lower CPIX numbers during the early months of 2005, but
for most of 2005, short-term rates are predicted to remain
fairly stable, rising by the second half of 2006. Our forecast
for total cash returns over the next twelve months is 7,5%.
Despite the weaker dollar and strongly
growing economy, the USA has not really been subjected to
excessive inflation worries. The reason for this is to be
found in some deflationary forces still at work in many
sectors and regions, rising levels of productivity, and
low capacity utilisation. The expectation is nevertheless
that the Fed will continue to tighten in 2005, with short-term
rates reaching around 3,5% in early 2006. Elsewhere, interest
rates could remain on hold as the European economies continue
to grapple with a strong euro and Japan moves only gradually
out of deflation.
Property
The return on the JSE Listed Property Index measured -49,5%
(annualised in dollar terms) in the first quarter of 2005,
although in rand terms the negative return was only -1,1%.
Over the past three years, total listed property returns
averaged 69% per annum in dollar terms and 36,9% in rand
terms, making this the best performing asset class over
this period.
Residential property market values have
increased very strongly over the past three years and are
set for another year of positive – albeit lower –
real growth in prices. However, it would appear that affordability
issues could be limiting any further capital gains in house
prices, while the buy-to-let market also seems to becoming
saturated.
According
to Rode’s Report on the SA Property Market, low vacancies
and almost 4% growth in manufacturing volumes since the
last quarter of 2003, resulted in robust growth in industrial
rental and stand values during 2004, and real industrial
rentals are still growing at a rate that beats building-cost-inflation.
Also according this report, the office market still appears
to struggle in certain places, especially in the Johannesburg
CBD. Vacancy levels have generally been declining and are
now at their long-term average levels. Retail property space
has been in huge demand and has led to a substantial decrease
in capitalisation rates (the equivalent to the earnings
yield on shares).
Given the positive outlook for inflation
and relatively low interest rates, both the listed property
sector and directly held property should continue to perform
well over the next twelve months. Other factors such as
declining vacancy rates and growing real rentals should
also underpin the market. Property returns (JSE-listed)
are expected to average some 35% in rand terms over the
next twelve months.
Note: Calculation
of returns
In accordance with the international convention, returns
on asset classes in this section were consistently based
on the monthly changes in indices in which income (interest
or dividends) were included. The geometric averages
obtained for, for instance, the three months of a quarter,
were then reduced to an annualised figure. Month-end
figures were used for indices and exchange rates. |