Deloitte’s
Fourth Bi-annual Global Risk Management Survey Says:
Risk Management Practices
in Top Financial Firms Continue to Evolve But Enterprise Risk
Management Remains Elusive
Elevation of the risk management
function and Basel II compliance challenges emerge as key
themes
by Edward T. Hida II, Partner & US Banking
Risk Management Practice Leader, Deloitte & Touche LLP
and Ingrid Goodspeed, Associate Director, Deloitte & Touche
South Africa

he
Sarbanes-Oxley Act in the U.S. and equivalent legislation
in other countries are changing the risk management landscape.
With the specter of criminal prosecution looming as a consequence
of non-compliance, financial institutions are tightening their
focus on the issues of corporate governance, board oversight,
financial disclosures and internal controls. At the same time,
they are facing growing exposure to risk from a variety of
factors, including mega-mergers, off-shoring, outsourcing,
and an increased volume of lending. The challenges of complying
with tough regulations while containing an expanding number
of risk factors were dramatically reflected in the results
of Deloitte’s bi-annual Global Risk Management Survey.
Over the past 8 years, Deloitte has undertaken
a rigorous analysis of and commentary on risk management issues
to provide financial services firms with a global benchmark
of trends and practices. This year’s survey contained
responses from 162 financial institutions with assets totaling
nearly $19 trillion located on five continents. Africa was
not included in this Global Risk Management Survey but will
be included in future The sample included responses from 12
financial services sectors in four broad categories: investment
banking and related services, commercial banking, integrated
financial services and retail banking. Deloitte’s last
Global Risk Management Survey was conducted in 2002.
Risk Governance:
The Continuing Rise of the CRO
Among the survey’s most compelling findings were the
continuing ascension of the risk management function in both
visibility and organizational importance. Eighty-one percent
of the respondents reported that they now have a Chief Risk
Officer (CRO), compared to 65% in the 2002 survey. The survey
also shows that three-quarters of CROs in financial services
firms now report to their chief executive or the board of
directors. . We would expect the percentage of respondents
having CROs to be higher in South Africa because banks are
required in terms of the Banks Act to have an independent
risk management function headed by an executive officer who
acts as the reference point for all aspects relating to risk
management within the bank. In addition the head of the risk
management function is responsible for arranging training
of members of the board in the different risk areas to which
that bank is exposed.
The survey also shed light on the role of
the CRO. Each institution’s risk appetite and culture
appears to influence the job description of the CRO, resulting
in some variation in the distribution of duties. However,
the results of this year’s survey are broadly consistent
with those from 2002 in terms of primary responsibilities
assigned to the CRO or independent risk oversight function:
- Risk analytics and reporting (85% considered primary responsibility)
- Developing controls, policies and monitoring compliance
(79%)
- Monitoring of risk exposure versus limits (74%)
- Independent verification of risk methodologies (70%)
Along with the growing prevalence and importance
of CROs, the overall responsibility for managing risk has
been elevated in many institutions to the board of directors
(38%) or a board-level risk management committee (21%), making
it a focal point of governance strategy. This represents a
25% increase in board-level oversight of risk management compared
to the previous survey and suggests an increasing trend toward
vesting responsibility at the highest level in the organization.
In South Africa responsibility for managing risk is placed
firmly in the hands of the board of directors. For example
Regulation 38 issued in terms of the Banks Act states “The
board of directors of a bank is ultimately responsible for
ensuring that an adequate and effective process of corporate
governance, which is consistent with the nature, complexity
and risk inherent in the bank’s on-balance-sheet and
off-balance-sheet activities and which responds to changes
in the banks environment and conditions, is established and
maintained.” In addition in terms of The King Report
on Corporate Governance for South Africa, the board is responsible
for the total process of risk management, as well as forming
its own opinion on the effectiveness of the process.
Regulatory
and Economic Capital: Basel II Progress and Challenges
The development of more sophisticated capital calculation
methodologies continues due to both business and regulatory
drivers – primarily Basel II. With the approaching implementation
date of Basel II, organizations are increasingly turning their
attention and resources toward developing the capabilities
needed to meet these new requirements. The greatest emphasis
has been on credit and operational risk due to the relative
maturity of market risk requirements.
South Africa is to implement Basel II on
1 January 2008. Errol Kruger the Registrar of Banks states
that South Africa complies with all the generally accepted
pre-conditions for the adoption of Basel II by a particular
country because
- its banking industry strives for best practice in risk
management and is continuing to entrench a culture of risk
management;
- Effective supervision of banks exists and South Africa
complies with the Basel Core Principles for Effective Supervision.
In addition legislation relating to companies, banks insolvency
and anti-money laundering is by and large up to international
standards. South Africa also complies with the standards
of the Basel Committee on Payments and Settlement Systems;
and
- South Africa has clear rules for disclosure and moving
to greater transparency. The country complies with and applies
International Financial Reporting Standards and International
Auditing Standards.
Credit Risk
Measurement
For credit risk, the Basel II Framework has encouraged banks
to develop more sophisticated regulatory capital calculation
frameworks based upon economic capital techniques. The Internal
Ratings Based (IRB) approaches – i.e., Foundation and
Advanced IRB (AIRB) – are the predominant methods that
respondents plan to use for their credit risk regulatory capital
frameworks. Yet, only a small minority of respondents consider
their current capabilities adequate to implement IRB Approaches
(10% of respondents stated that they are currently Foundation
IRB capable, and 7% consider themselves to be AIRB ready).
Based on current capabilities and stated plans, we expect
Basel II related activities to continue to gather momentum
within the credit risk functions of large internationally
active banks.
From an implementation perspective, significant
numbers of respondents report that more progress is needed
around data and system issues, underscoring the fact that
the Basel II Framework places tremendous importance on data
(i.e. availability, granularity, and validity) and system
infrastructure. In our view, the data-related challenges are
not entirely unexpected given the extensive M & A and
consolidation activity within the banking industry over the
last two decades. A myriad of disparate legacy systems and
data infrastructure continue to exist at most large banks
where integration-related interim solutions and tactical fixes
have become institutionalized. Basel II data requirements
are exposing the limitations of such solutions.
Process refinements and methodology development
are also inherently required in support of Basel II compliance
efforts. In addition to extensive reliance on data, the IRB
Approach has considerable process-oriented qualification requirements
(e.g., risk rating processes, underwriting, credit administration,
credit review and control, collateral management, etc.). In
many instances, gap assessments vis-a-vis qualification standards
and implementation requirements are forcing banks to modify
policies and procedures, change credit and documentation processes,
and review governance and control structures.
Operational
Risk Measurement
For operational risk, the Basel II Framework has helped spur
substantial development of quantitative measures for this
difficult-to-measure risk type. A majority of respondents
(54%) indicated that they plan to implement the most sophisticated
operational risk approach available in the Basel II Framework
– the Advanced Measurement Approach (AMA). Similar to
credit risk results, only a small minority believe they are
in a position to currently comply with the AMA requirements
(6%) or with the intermediate Standardized Approach (18%).
Consistent with our expectation, operational risk measurement
is still widely considered a much more immature field than
credit risk measurement, perhaps implying that relatively
more work needs to be done in the area of operational risk
than credit risk.
Respondents’ concerns regarding operational
risk measurement issues are distributed fairly evenly across
a host of issues. A majority of respondents indicate that
quantitative metrics and associated data acquisition issues
are of major concern to them. In our view, this response emphasizes
the fact that the firms feel less confident in their ability
to implement AMA due to issues with availability and analysis
of internal loss data (or lack thereof) and key risk indicators
that are aligned in a Basel II Framework fashion (i.e., across
defined Basel business lines and loss event categories).
Also, the Basel II Framework is much less
prescriptive with respect to operational risk AMA requirements
relative to those for credit risk AIRB. Accordingly, 57% of
respondents identified understanding regulatory expectations
as a “major concern,” while other quantitative
issues such as “loss history data” (60%), “data
integrity” (61%), and “capital allocation”
(54%) were also viewed as critical issues. Although the Basel
II Framework allows banks to be more flexible and unique in
their respective approach for AMA compliance, it also may
not provide sufficient guidance with respect to these requirements.
Given that formalized operational risk measurement and management
is still in a stage of infancy in most banks, there appears
to be a lack of clarity with respect to the tactical aspects
of Basel II requirements for operational risk AMA.
These results emphasize that Basel II compliance
represents a significant challenge for financial institutions.
There is no quick fix. It is an evolutionary process that
requires substantial, ongoing investment.
While compliance with regulatory requirements
is an imperative itself, we see major institutions using this
opportunity to transform the way they look at economic capital
and even their finance functions. A continuing challenge is
the applicability and practicality of these efforts for smaller
and mid-size institutions that may feel pressure from the
development of more sophisticated capital approaches at larger
institutions.
Other Areas
of Investment and Development
Beyond Basel II compliance, business factors and a tougher
overall regulatory environment are also driving continued
investment and development more broadly across the risk management
space. Areas in which this evolution is particularly evident
include credit risk management, risk systems and technology,
and extended enterprise solutions.
Credit Risk
Management
Since our last survey in 2002, credit risk management is an
area that has received significant attention at financial
institutions. The influence of Basel II requirements, commercial
credit market difficulties, and increased lending volume spurred
by low interest rates in the consumer sector have caused management
to focus more of their attention on strengthening their credit
risk capabilities. In addition, most organizations are constantly
looking to place available capital in the areas with the greatest
return per unit of risk. For financial institutions with commercial
and/or consumer credit risk, many have realized that improvements
in credit infrastructure are an excellent area for investment
that can improve bottom line results.
Much of this effort has focused on core capabilities.
These core capabilities include benchmarking of internal ratings
where 72% of survey participants report that they regularly
engage in this exercise (up from 54% in the prior survey).
Respondents are also using more sophisticated portfolio management
methodologies and credit mitigation techniques. These include
a 20% increase in usage of on/off balance sheet netting while
use of credit derivatives increased significantly, especially
among the largest firms.
New to the survey this year were questions
inquiring about investment priorities in both commercial and
consumer credit risk management capabilities over the next
12-24 months. In the commercial credit area, 62% of respondents
are planning a high or moderate level of investment in the
next 12-24 months. The most critical areas appear to be “active
portfolio management” (71% plan high or moderate investment),
Basel II (70%), reporting and management review of credit
decisions (70%), and consistent data/corporate aggregation
(70%). These top areas seem to point to increased sophistication,
but also a need to attend to basic issues around credit data,
which would be required to properly use more sophisticated
credit techniques and to meet the advanced requirements of
Basel II.
In the consumer credit area, 53% of respondents
are planning a high or moderate level of investment in the
next 12-24 months. The area receiving the most attention is
“global consistency of underwriting processes and standards”
where 36% of respondents plan a high level of investment,
and 27% see moderate investments in the near future. A focus
on movement toward risk-based collections and the usage of
scoring and collections results in customer profitability
measures are also important as a majority of respondents plan
moderate or high levels of investment in these capabilities.
These areas of top investment seem to make sense in a marketplace
where hyper-growth has taken place due to low interest rates
and competitive pressures leading to several recent consumer-focused
mergers. As large volume growth and mergers occur, consistency
of processes and underwriting becomes critical to gaining
efficiency and controlling risk. Moreover, as competition
increases, measures of customer profitability and high-impact
collections activities can become key differentiators.
Risk Systems
and Technology
Another area that has advanced considerably since our last
survey is risk systems and technology. Changes in the pricing
and design of hardware, the expansion of open source operating
systems and applications and the ongoing increase in the use
of advanced delivery mechanisms have continued to have a profound
impact on the design and functionality of risk systems. Despite
these advances, respondents report a host of continuing challenges
in developing adequate risk systems. System integration continues
to be the biggest challenge facing firms, with more than half
(52%) citing a lack of integration among systems as a major
concern and (42%) citing it as a minor concern. Respondents
also cited concerns with methodologies becoming out-dated,
existing platforms that are perceived to be inflexible and
difficult to extend, insufficient product coverage, lower
performance and rising maintenance costs.
In addition, the importance of regulatory
reporting has grown markedly since our last survey, and it
is no surprise that it ranks the highest in our participant’s
ratings, marginally ahead of the requirement for operational
risk and advanced credit risk systems. The impact of the Sarbanes-Oxley
requirements in the United States and equivalent requirements
elsewhere, the ongoing efforts to achieve Basel II compliance
and the growing demands to address anti-money laundering and
related issues have focused business attention on this area
– 75% of respondents identified regulatory risk-reporting
as a moderate or high priority. When the results for advanced
credit risk systems (39% “high priority”) and
operational risk measurement (39% “high priority”)
are also considered, the impact that advanced regulatory reporting
requirements such as Basel II are having and will continue
to have on the risk platforms of respondents becomes readily
apparent.
Extended Enterprise
Solutions
With each of our global risk management surveys, we identify
new areas that are garnering meaningful attention across the
financial services industry and consider whether they should
be included. In this year’s survey, the topic of Extended
Enterprise (EE) solutions was selected due to its high visibility
and the potential challenges and risks in managing these business
arrangements.
When it comes to off-shoring or near-shoring
arrangement (i.e., the movement of business processes from
developed economies to lower cost offshore locations) and
outsourcing arrangements across a variety of corporate functions,
survey respondents reported that information technology and
application management was the only area where a majority
(61%) employed an extended enterprise solution. Call centers
and back-office processes were areas where a near majority
(47%) employed one or more EE solutions, while “human
resources” and “collections and payment processing”
were cited by around 40% of respondents.
Although EE solutions often provide significant
benefits to an organization in terms of cost reduction and
efficiency, these arrangements create a new set of risks that
must be managed. Respondents indicated that operational (83%),
and IT (82%) risks were of highest concern (sum of medium
plus high-risk categories). This is not surprising given the
technical and process complexities of employing EE solutions
for one or more functions within a company. Of some concern
to respondents were confidentiality, regulatory and reputation
risks (all ranging between 60% and 70% for the sum of medium
plus high-risk responses). Interestingly, respondents did
not consider geopolitical risk to be a significant concern
with 63% rating it a low risk.
We also queried survey participants on the
methods or techniques employed to manage EE risks. The most
common methods, based on rates of adoption, include written
contracts and service level agreements (85%), formal vendor
selection and due diligence (74%), and regular internal audits
(69%). Also, a majority of respondents cited the use of documented
vendor oversight policies (52%) and business continuity planning
as part of their EE risk management efforts.
While EE solutions are growing, and organizations
are using risk management techniques, significant challenges
remain regarding the level of integration between EE solutions
and an institution’s risk identification management
and monitoring processes. Less than a quarter (24%) of respondents
considered their EE solutions’ risk management capabilities
to be very integrated, while slightly less than half (45%)
considered them somewhat integrated. Nearly one-third (31%)
of participants thought their EE solutions and their institutional
risk management programs were not integrated at all.
South Africa scores highly as an offshoring
location because of its sophisticated financial services environment,
high levels of industry expertise, political stability, and
English proficiency
Enterprise
Risk Management Remains an Elusive Goal
Despite the increasing emphasis on containing risk, the survey
shows that enterprise risk management (ERM) continues to be
an elusive goal for many institutions. In fact, less than
one-quarter of survey participants say they are able to integrate
risk across any of the major dimensions of risk type, business
unit, or geography. Respondents indicated a continued focus
on measuring economic risks including credit, market, operational
and liquidity within their ERM frameworks. Using the integration
of market and credit risk management programs as a proxy for
risk consolidation progress, 38% of participants reported
integrating the organizational structure for these risks,
but much lower responses were received for integrating methodology,
data and systems (between 15% and 16% for each).
Our survey also asked respondents to rate
their most significant ERM implementation challenges. Not
surprisingly, “systems integration and automation”
continues its reign as the most challenging aspect of integrating
market and credit risk capabilities with a majority of respondents
(51%) choosing that answer. Slightly less than half of respondents
(45%) indicted that “data clean-up and consolidation”
was the most challenging aspect of integration. These results
show that technology and data issues continue to pose the
greatest barrier to achieving a consistent level of risk consolidation
across the enterprise. Extending beyond market and credit
risk to include other risk types will entail even greater
challenges.
Tougher regulatory
environment
The survey finds that a tougher regulatory environment and
increased scrutiny of financial institutions in the post-Enron
business environment have contributed appreciably to a greater
emphasis on risk management. Apart from implementation of
Basel II, additional proposed legislation that South African
banks must grapple with include the National Credit Bill and
the Dedicated and Co-operative Banks Bills. In addition banks
and other financial services firms must deal with the implementation
of the Financial Sector Charter - a voluntary commitment by
the financial services industry to transformation and Black
Economic Empowerment.
The Evolution
Continues
Overall, the survey results reflect the fact that the financial
services industry is faced with growing exposure to risk and
a heightened urgency to contain it. Despite major strides
forward in the areas of risk governance and regulatory compliance,
the survey also reveals the enigma of risk management –
effective integration of risk management methodology, data
and systems remains elusive. Consequently, ERM will be a major
focus within financial institutions for some time, requiring
the continued evolution of processes, instruments and systems
as well as the expenditure of much effort and resources to
achieve a truly consolidated, enterprise-wide view of a firm’s
risks.
About the Survey
Deloitte invited senior risk management officers of the world’s
top financial institutions to use an online tool to complete
a comprehensive set of questions about risk management. Responses
were received from 162 financial institutions with assets
totaling nearly US$19 trillion located on five continents.
Approximately 65 percent of the responses were from firms
with assets ranging from $10 billion to more than $100 billion.
Respondents broke out regionally as follows: 17% percent of
respondents were North American companies; 25% were South
American companies; 26% were European companies; and 31% were
from Asia/Pacific. Respondents answered detailed questions
which addressed a range of key risk management issues facing
financial institutions including: Risk Governance, Economic
and Regulatory Capital, Enterprise Risk Management, Credit
Risk Management, Market Risk and Asset/Liability Management,
Operational Risk Management, Risk Systems and Technology and
Extended Enterprise Solutions. The Global Risk Management
survey, which is the largest and most comprehensive of its
kind, is conducted every two years and it is envisaged that
African financial institutions will be included in future
surveys
To Find Out
More
A complimentary copy of the complete survey report may be
downloaded via www.deloitte.com.
For more information contact
Ingrid Goodspeed of Deloitte South Africa’s Financial
Risk Advisory Services Division (FRAS) on 011 806 5200. FRAS
offers financial risk advisory services encompassing financial
and operational risks, asset liability management, performance
benchmarking and capital optimisation to clients in the financial
services industry. In addition the division provides advisory
services to corporate treasuries including treasury risk management
best practice reviews.
Edward T. Hida II, a Partner
with Deloitte & Touche LLP, serves large banking, derivatives
and securities dealer clients, spanning the range of risk
management issues from policies, procedures, governance and
infrastructure to methodology, quantitative techniques and
systems. |