Introduction
to Metal Exchanges
By Ingrid Goodspeed, Associate Director Deloitte

n
February 2005 Lulu Xingwana, Deputy Minister of Minerals and
Energy, announced that “Johannesburg could become the
centre for a Pan-African Metals and Minerals Exchange trading
diamonds, gold, platinum, cobalt, aluminium, ferro-alloys,
gemstones, titanium oxide and copper”. An independent
consultancy, Virtual Metals has been appointed to undertake
a study into the feasibility of establishing such an exchange.
The objectives of this article are to outline the global environment
into which the Johannesburg Metals Exchange will be launched
and describe the key elements that determine the likelihood
of success for a metals exchange initiative. Since each metal
has unique market conventions, this article will focus, where
appropriate, on gold trading.
1. What is a metals exchange
A metals exchange is a centralized market in which metals
are bought and sold. The exchange not only allows metals to
be sold spot or for delivery at some specified time and place,
but may include a market in futures. The futures market will
allow participants to avoid the effects of price fluctuations
by buying / selling for forward delivery at a specific price
that will not be impacted by changes in the spot price.
Metals exchanges provide a mechanism
- to improve the quantity and quality
of information – including price information - to
all those active in the production, trade, processing and
consumption of metals;
- reduce the cost of identifying market sources,:
- make available an efficient system of grading and improve
the reliability of quality standards;
- give security in trade transactions;
- facilitate access to relatively cheap metals finance;
and
- assist in price risk management.
2. Global Metal Trading
The global trade in metals consists of over-the-counter (OTC)
transactions in spot, forwards, options and other more-complex
derivatives together with exchange-traded futures and options.
Exchange-traded futures and options contracts are standardised
so that each contract traded is of the same quantity and purity
of metal as all other contracts in that commodity. In addition
the place of delivery – if delivery is made –
is specified, as is the period within which delivery must
take place. Generally less than 1% of futures contracts come
to delivery as the majority of clients close out their futures
positions before expiry date and deliver or take delivery
through OTC channels - futures and options being used to hedge
price risk. On the other hand, OTC forward or options contracts
may be of any size or delivery date subject to the agreement
reached between the counterparties to the agreement.
The forward or future price is a function of the underlying
spot price, prevailing interest rates in the money markets
and costs such as insurance and storage.
Table 1 shows the most important metals exchanges in the
world and the metals traded on them. Gold and silver are traded
on all exchanges except London Metals Exchange and Tehran
Metals Exchange.
| Table 1: Metals exchanges and metals
traded |
| Exchange |
Gold |
Platinum |
Paladium |
Silver |
Copper |
Aluminium |
Lead |
Nickel |
Tin |
Zinc |
| Chicago Board of Trade |
x |
|
|
x |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Dubai Gold & Commodities Exchange
|
x |
|
|
x |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Istanbul Gold Exchange |
x |
x |
|
x |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| London Metal Exchange |
|
|
|
|
x |
x |
x |
x |
x |
x |
| National Commodity & Derivatives
Exchange Limited (India) |
x |
|
x |
x |
x |
|
|
|
|
|
| New York Mercantile Exchange: Commodity
Exchange Division |
x |
|
|
x |
x |
x |
|
|
|
|
| Shanghai Futures Exchange |
x |
|
|
|
x |
x |
x |
x |
x |
x |
| Tokyo Commodity Exchange |
x |
x |
x |
x |
x |
x |
|
|
|
|
| Tehran Metals Exchange |
|
|
|
|
x |
x |
|
|
|
x |
Table 2 shows the number of futures and options contracts
per annum traded on the major global metal exchanges. The
two main exchanges for gold and silver are Comex (the Commodity
Exchange Division of New York Mercantile Exchange) and Tocom
(Tokyo Commodity Exchange). In 2004 the average daily turnover
represented by futures contracts traded on Comex and Tocom
was 9.7million ounces of gold and 101.4 million ounces of
silver.
| Table 2: Metal Exchanges and contracts
traded |
| Exchange |
Instrument |
Source Data |
Number of contracts ('000) |
% Total Futures |
% Total Options |
Gold Futures |
% Total Futures |
| Chicago Board of trade |
Futures |
Nov-04 |
727 |
0.4 |
|
510 |
1.5 |
| London Metal Exchange |
Futures
Options |
Dec-04 |
67 172
4 612 |
39.7 |
45.2
|
|
|
| New York Mercantile Exchange: |
Futures |
Dec-04 |
24 916 |
14.7 |
|
16 061 |
|
| Commodity Exchange Division |
Options |
Dec-04 |
5 527 |
|
54.2 |
|
|
| Tokyo Commodity Exchange |
Futures
Options |
Dec-04
Dec-04 |
|
44.0 |
|
17 386 |
51.2 |
| Shanghai Futures Exchange |
Futures |
Feb-04 |
1 880 |
1.1 |
|
|
|
| Totals |
Futures
Options |
|
169 142
10 203 |
100.0 |
100.0 |
33 957 |
100.0 |
| 179
345 |
The bulk of global trade in gold and silver takes place over-the-counter
(OTC). London is the largest global centre for OTC transactions
followed by New York, Zurich and Tokyo. Although the physical
market for gold and silver is distributed globally, most OTC
transactions are cleared through London. In December 2004
the average daily volume of gold and silver cleared through
the London Bullion Market Association was respectively 15.4million
ounces (USD6.8billion) and 102.2million ounces (USD730million).
3. Characteristics of a successful
metals exchange
The following are characteristics of a successful metals exchange,
indeed of any exchange:
- Liquidity: The real asset of any exchange is liquidity.
The larger the liquidity pool the more attractive the market
is to participants;
- Open participation: The market should be open and accessible
to many participants – investors speculators, producers
and consumers, corporate treasurers, commercial and investment
banks, brokers / dealers and individuals as part of their
financial management strategy;
- Standardised systems: The exchange should have standardised
and robust systems for trading, clearing , settlement and
custody;
- Sound clearing systems: The clearing system of the exchange
should provide assurance to all participants that counterparties
to each trade will make good on the contract;
- Standardised contracts: The exchange should have standardised
contracts in terms of quality and quantity specifications
and delivery points; and
- Good governance: The exchange should be well managed with
sound rules, governance and risk management.
4. Conclusion
Given the current global competitive environment, the question
– is there room for another metals exchange? –
must be a key question to be answered by the feasibility study
into the establishment of Johannesburg Metals Exchange. Above
all the metals exchange should not be a status symbol but
should meet the needs of its constituents and allow those
active in the underlying metals markets – whether producers,
traders, manufacturers or consumers – to reduce transaction
costs and improve the manner in which they operate. Failing
this there is little chance the exchange will survive.
Nonetheless a metals exchange has the potential to contribute
to the economic development of Southern Africa and the well-being
of its population.
Sources and bibliography
UNCTAD Secretariat, 2001, Overview of the World’s
Commodity Exchanges, www.unctad.org;
UNCTAD Secretariat, 1997, Emerging commodity exchanges: from
potential to success, www.unctad.org;
International Financial Services, London, 2005, Bullion Markets,
www.ifsl.org.uk;
Websites of the exchanges;
www.lbma.org.uk;
www.gold.org.
|