Fit
and Proper: An update on developments
By Charene Nortier
Manager: Supervision, FAIS Department
FSB

recent
article discussed the past, present and future of the Fit
and Proper requirements of the FAIS Act, 2002. This article
discusses ideas on future developments. The Fit and Proper
Forum is supported by seven working groups, which span the
financial services industry. The following is an overview
of the discussions and deliberations, of the Forum, the results
of which have not yet been finalised.
Who is affected?
According to the Determination of Fit and
Proper Requirements for Financial Service Providers, Board
Notice 91 of 2006, three persons are affected by Fit and Proper
requirements: the applicant, key individual and representative.
The applicant is the financial services provider.
In the case of a sole proprietor, the applicant is also the
sole proprietor. The law regards the person who applies for
a licence as the applicant. In other words, if Mr Xoko applies
for a licence to act as a financial services provider, as
he wants to set himself up as an independent broker selling
life insurance, and he acts as a sole proprietor, he is the
applicant.
There are different ways in which a key individual
can act. In the Financial Advisory and Intermediary Services
Act, 2002 (FAIS Act), a “key individual” in relation
to an authorised financial services provider, or representative,
carrying on business as –
- a corporate or unincorporated body, a trust or a partnership,
means any natural person responsible for managing or overseeing,
either alone or together with other so responsible persons,
the activities of the body, trust or partnership relating
to the rendering of any financial service; or
- a corporate body or trust consisting of only one natural
person as a member, director, shareholder or trustee,
means any such natural person;”
Given the above definition, it is useful
to clarify how the key individual looks, and what he/she needs
to comply with:
Activity
|
Key individual
option 1 |
Key individual
option 2 |
Key individual
option 3 |
Key individual
option 4 |
Manage &
oversee the activities of the business/ part of the
business |
x
|
x |
x |
x |
Manage &
oversee the business or part thereof and also manages
the representatives |
1 |
x |
1 |
x |
Manage and
oversee the business or part thereof and also act
as a representative (own clients) |
1 |
1 |
x |
x |
From this table, it is clear that the common
denominator is always the responsibility to manage and oversee
the activities of the business or part thereof. This is the
crux of the matter – if the person does not have this
responsibility, he/she does not meet the criteria of the definition.
The second issue is to establish whether the key individual
also manages and oversees representatives and the third, to
establish whether he/she also acts as a representative. Should
such a person should be formally appointed as a key individual
in addition to the appointment as representative, this person
must then meet the requirements imposed on both key individuals
and representatives.
The third person in terms of Fit and Proper
requirements is the representative. The representative is
the individual who, after appointment by the financial services
provider, gives advice to clients regarding financial products
or renders intermediary services in connection with the products.
One must remember that not everyone who works for a financial
services provider is automatically a representative. Representatives
are those people whose activities are defined under “advice”
or “intermediary services” in the FAIS Act.
Experience
requirements
Although there are ongoing discussions, the
indications are the following:
- There will still be experience requirements, but there
will be a difference between the experience required for
advice and for intermediary services;
- In most instances, the experience requirement will
be more onerous for advice than for intermediary services;
- Experience can be gained simultaneously if a representative
is appointed for multiple financial products; and
- The experience requirement does not default to the
financial product with the most onerous requirement. It
means that the representative must gain experience against
all the financial products he/she is appointed for, and
a record must be kept of the process.
Representatives without the relevant experience
can be appointed, and will serve under supervision until they
have met the experience requirements. Applicants and key individuals
must have the required experience before they can be appointed
for a specific financial product or category.
Key individuals will be required to provide
proof of the following types of experience:
- Management and oversight of financial services business;
- Deciding how the services are rendered;
- Actually rendering the services; or
- Supervising those who render the services.
Qualification
requirements
Minimum qualification requirements will still
be applicable to all categories. These requirements will depend
on the complexity of the financial products. As a result,
current thinking identifies two groups of financial products
with simple minimum qualification requirements, namely Long-term
Insurance Category A (funeral assistance business) and Friendly
Society Benefits. Although the decision has not been made,
indications are that it will hinge around the ability to show
basic literacy and numeracy in the language used, rather than
a formal scholastic level. This approach is pragmatic, as
there are many operators in the informal economy that do not
have documents proving their school leaving status.
Again, although not final, indications are
that the minimum qualifications requirement for the other
financial products in category I will be Matric or equivalent
qualifications, and a NQF level 6 qualification for Categories
II and III. The NQF level 6 qualifications will need to be
appropriate to the financial services industry. The list of
appropriate subjects will be changed where necessary.
The current “column four” or
“conditions/restrictions” requirements in terms
of Fit and Proper requirements will be replaced with a new
set of requirements. There will probably be two types of acceptable
options in this regard:
- Results of examinations against set standards/criteria;
or
- Qualifications that meet the requirements.
The set of qualifying examinations will be
based on criteria that address the following:
- Core criteria that deal with:
- the requirements of the FAIS Act and subordinate
legislation;
- specific legislation relevant to certain financial
products; and
- other general standards that apply to all financial
products and categories
- Specific criteria for key individuals and compliance
officers (this includes people who act as their own compliance
officers);
- Criteria relevant to specialist classes:
- Product related criteria that differentiate between
advice and intermediary services
These requirements are intended to ensure
that applicants, key individuals, representatives and compliance
officers actually know and understand the legislative requirements
and specific duties they execute on behalf of the financial
services provider.
Services under
supervision
The current exemption in terms of services
under supervision only addresses representatives who do not
have the required experience regarding a specific financial
product, and is also limited to Category I financial services
providers. The proposal is that the services under supervision
will be included in the Fit and Proper requirements, and that
it will apply to all representatives, regardless of the category
of financial services rendered. If a financial services provider
appoints a representative, who only meets the minimum qualifications
requirements, the representative will in future function under
supervision until he/she meets the experience and qualifying
criteria requirements.
Let’s consider this scenario:
- The ITU Financial Services Provider appoints Ms Nkewu
as a representative when she completes Matric.
- She is appointed to give advice on Long-term Insurance
Category B products.
- She will work under supervision until she has completed:
- her qualifying exams (she has five years from appointment);
and
- the relevant experience has been gained (at least
one year).
- At the end of her first year of appointment Mr Itu,
her supervisor, is satisfied with her progress, but she
has only completed half of the relevant qualifying examinations
applicable to her role.
- She will remain under supervision until she completes
the rest of the qualifying examinations.
There will be more detailed guidelines clarifying
what will be accepted as proper supervision, to ensure that
there is parity in terms of the standards applied. The approach
will be more principles-based, with the principles underlying
the provision of services under supervision clearly stipulated.
Financial services providers can expect that
the principles will be similar across categories I to III,
with representatives under supervision in Category II and
III financial services providers subject to stricter controls.
Continuous
Professional Development (CPD)
The industry consensus is that CPD “is
a good idea in theory, but how will it work”? There
are professional organisations that have successfully implemented
CPD requirements for a long time, and their approaches will
certainly be studied in depth. Some of the concerns include:
- CPD requirements should have real value for the industry,
and not create a situation where people merely participate
in a “points” gathering exercise;
- The logistical issues of providing CPD-related activities
over the wide geographic spread in the country;
- The cost of CPD initiatives should not be prohibitive;
- Accessibility is an issue – this impacts on face-to-face
delivery and electronic delivery.
Timelines
- The timelines that the Fit and Proper Forum is working
towards are:
- Industry consultation – mid-February 2008;
- Draft Fit and Proper requirements presented to the
FAIS Advisory Committee – March 2008;
- Transitional arrangements agreed and published –
mid-year 2008
- New Fit and Proper requirements published – third
quarter of 2008
- Implementation of transitional arrangements –
2009
Conclusion
The Fit and Proper Forum, with the support
of the working groups still has many issues to deal with.
The progress to date has been impressive, and the FSB would
like to thank the institutions, professional bodies, corporate
institutions, individuals, SAQA and the financial SETAs for
their contributions and participation. Without their continued
participation the development of new, pragmatic and practical
Fit and Proper requirements would not be possible.
|