Carbon
foot printing as a way forward into a low carbon society
By Peter Oldacre

The International
Climate Change Developments:
The science:

ver the last 18 months the science around climate change has
become more certain and also more worrying. The latest assessment
was presented by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change
(IPCC) late in 2007, which involved more than 2500 scientists
and 130 countries. The panel concluded that the warming of
the climate system is unequivocal and that it is with more
than 90% caused by human activity.(1)
The Policy:
Policy also moved forward with the UN Meeting in Bali in December
2007 reaching agreement that a successor to the Kyoto Protocol
would be finalized by December 2009. The roadmap revolves
around key areas such as climate change mitigation, adaptation,
technology transfer and financing initiatives.
In the United States we have seen senate
sponsored proposals for firm carbon targets and the state
level initiatives such as the Regional Green house Gas Initiative
are now being implemented. The European Commission has strengthened
the EU Trading Scheme in time for phase three of this initiative
which starts in 2013.
Carbon Markets saw tremendous growth and
a value of some 90 billion US Dollars in 2008; almost double
what it was worth in 2007 and the market looks set to rise
again in value for 2009. The majority of the value traded
was an instrument called a Certified Emission Reduction (CER)
which is derived from the aforementioned Kyoto Protocol and
a mechanism known as the Clean Development Mechanism (CDM).
The market is beginning to mature, with a greater understanding
of how to price carbon risk and increasing product sophistication.
The last year also saw more corporate engagement with the
climate change agenda, with many leading companies taking
active and public stances on climate change. Companies are
increasingly concerned about the impacts of regulation and
the physical impacts of climate change. There are also very
real opportunities that climate change represents through
new and changing markets, new technology and the transition
to a low carbon economy.
2009 is set to be a defining year on the
climate change agenda with the Copenhagen climate conference
in December being eagerly and fearfully watched for a signal
to guide the bold scientific, social and economic imperatives
that are needed to meet this challenge.
The National
Climate Change Developments:
Although small in relative terms at around
1% of global emissions, South Africa’s emissions are
large in relation to its population and to its economy. This
is in comparison to most developing as well as developed nations.
Presently, our per capita emissions are higher than both India
and China.
Our need for growth and development coupled
to our high relative emissions provides policy makers with
tough choices. We need as a rule 6% growth in the economy
between 2010 and 2014 to meet the UN Millennium Development
Goals, this while we as a country have been identified as
one of the region’s most vulnerable to the impacts of
climate change. Our economy and our power generation sector
is primarily based on coal, which is highly carbon intensive
and in all truth there is probably very little that can be
done within the next decade to change this. South Africa will
need to reduce its energy intensity and begin to rely on alternative
forms of power generation to “decarbonise” its
economy and to minimize the adverse effects of contributing
to climate change.
One of the aspects that South Africa will
have to come to terms with in the very near future is that,
alongside mitigation techniques such as reducing carbon footprints
and trading carbon, South Africa will have to begin to prepare
for adaptation to the physical changes that climate change
will bring. Recent studies(2) have shown that the areas of
highest vulnerability are in the health sector, maize production,
plant and animal biodiversity, water resources and rangelands.
The most concerning area given the press exposures over the
last year for me are definitely the issues on water quality
and availability. Water quality and availability is already
seen as a limiting factor to economic growth and development
and it is anticipated that this can worsen dramatically. Although
South Africa is vulnerable to climate change, it must also
be remembered that we at least have access to greater resources
and that we have greater capacity to adapt than most, if not
all of our neighbours. The aim of adaptation is to reduce
vulnerability caused by current climate changes and somehow
provide protections against projected future changes, together
with developing any new opportunities which may arise.
Adaptation will include things like a need
for improved physical infrastructure to handle different weather
patterns, things like storms drains to handle a change in
street run off. Avoiding development in flood prone areas,
anyone that has built their house in Knysna below the 100
year flood line will wake up to a changed landscape one morning
in the future. Improved flows of information between networks,
knowledge sharing and skills development are going to be paramount
to adaptation. The list can go on and on, and hopefully the
context of what we are talking about for South Africa is clear.
The first step in any business adapting to climate change
is to start with a proactive engagement with scientists, governments
and civil society on the matter to ensure that efforts are
aligned. Practically the first step from which a measurement
can be taken is then referred to as a carbon foot print. A
carbon foot print for better or worse is exactly what it sounds
like – it is a foot print, taken at a given time, of
a company’s carbon emission profile and can be as simple
or as complex as needed. Some foot prints will ring fence
only the company’s direct activities inside a physical
boundary, others will include the use of electricity, which,
while not the direct responsibility of the company using the
electricity, is still a contributor to the country’s
foot print, and others will go so far as to measure their
“outside the physical boundary” travel based emissions.
The result is a benchmark against which to repeatedly measure
as time goes by or sometimes even a disclosure to a holding
company based on other countries regulatory requirements.
The Carbon
Disclosure Project:
The Carbon Disclosure Project is the largest
Investor coalition in the World, with more than 385 signatory
investors and more than 57 trillion US Dollars in combined
asset base. More than 3000 companies worldwide, in more than
30 countries were involved in the collection of information
and data from which to develop a regional response to climate
change. The CDP takes the form of a series of questions and
answers which benchmark what and how a company is dealing
with and measuring their carbon emissions. A basic foot print
of their emissions is established. In South Africa, the CDP
has as its five key objectives to:
- Provide Institutional investors with information which
facilitates a better understanding of the risks and opportunities
stemming from climate change.
- Highlight best practices in activities to address climate
change across a range of sectors.
- Benchmark actions and disclosure between sectors and
companies.
- Analyse key issues in relation to climate change disclosure.
- Use companies responses as a way to identify key concerns,
challenges and future directions around carbon disclosure.
JSE top 100
Responses:
In terms of responses to the current Carbon
Disclosure Project, which is a response based on first completing
a carbon foot print, the top 100 companies in South Africa
identified the following as risks. These risks, which are
going to be sector specific and in perceived importance include:
- Physical risks related to water and energy availability,
as well as the increased costs to deal with these issues.
- Regulatory risks around energy use, GHG emission controls
and the costs associated with complying to these mandated
actions.
- Reputational risk form companies not actively addressing
climate change.
In terms of opportunities, the following
issues were identified:
- Potential for trading emissions and renewable energy
projects.
- The potential for new business to meet changing consumer
demand.
- Enhanced reputational benefits.
- Potential opportunities from implementing more energy
efficient and emissions reducing technology.
Carbon Credits:
Very simply put and in terms of one of the
opportunities identified under the Carbon Disclosure Project,
the best way to identify carbon credit trading opportunities
is to take an approach which first identifies all the possible
areas where an organisation is carbon intensive. Doing this
carbon foot print will enable a focus to be developed that
makes the most sense in terms of finding the area for mitigating
action in an organization that represents the most bang for
buck. If mitigation techniques are undertaken with the Kyoto
Protocol in mind, carbon credits may be derived from the mitigation
activity and in doing so an extra source of cash flow can
be created for a company that in some cases is substantial.
In terms of how carbon credits can be turned
into cash flow, the model is best explained by using what
is called the primary market, or in carbon speak – the
compliance market. Emitters in more developed countries are
compliance bound to reduce their emissions and one of the
tools available to them is to buy emission reductions from
somewhere else in the World to “prove” that they
are active in reducing emissions. It’s really as simple
as that and while it can be very much more complicated, it
does not have to be in order to gain a basic understanding
of emissions trading. Generally the compliance market is a
primary market and the emission reductions are traded over
the counter, but time has seen a secondary market which is
interesting and analogous to many of the types of business
that go in the financial markets across the World. An interesting
angle on secondary markets is partially expounded on below
by Gar Lipow. The point behind Gar’s comments is to
show how the emissions market is encouraging vigorous and
interesting debate.
In solving the climate crisis we need
to avoid creating the type of large secondary emissions trading
market Kyoto did. Large secondary emission markets constitute
a whole new sector with strong incentives that conflict with
a really large drop in emissions. Maybe carbon traders are
so noble and dedicated to saving the planet that financial
self-interest won't influence them. But, if your view of human
nature is that incentives matter, then a strong secondary
market creates a group of people with the wrong ones. If incentives
matter, then a secondary carbon market runs a real risk of
becoming the
new sub-prime.
For example, it has been noted that the
European Emission Trading Scheme and other emission markets
tend to be subject to high volatility, something that undercuts
long term success. Large price variations for emissions permits
discourage long term investment in savings, because it is
hard to predict the value of the savings. Volatility
can also lead to crashes, where emission prices temporarily
drop near zero, which further reduces
investment in reductions. The problem is traders tend
to profit in the short term from volatility, because prices
that vary encourage a larger number of transactions; more
transactions produce more profit. While there are regulatory
approaches that can discourage such volatility, such as high
mandatory minimum emissions prices, financial industries in
general tend to resist this type of regulation.
Within finance, the short-term profits
the regulations would cost are sharply felt as real. The long-term
dangers are dismissed as airy theories, or perhaps dismissed
as problems the industry is confident it can handle without
government aid. And then the theories turn out not be so airy,
and the masters of the universe accepts trillion dollar bailouts.
But perhaps the emissions trading industry is too altruistic
and noble to act like typical financial institutions, and
will support stringent regulation to reduce volatility.
My personal opinion is that the volatility
that is experienced in the markets comes from an interpretation
of how the fundamentals of supply and demand are being affected,
and what policy makers are doing to influence those supply
and demand criteria. I like the idea of a large secondary
market to take the risk away from the primary market. If the
market is effective in mitigating the risk in the primary
market, we will see continued investment into carbon reduction
strategies that involve carbon credits, and while it makes
the secondary market somewhat of a hairy place to be, the
emergence of the secondary market goes towards showing that
the emissions trading space is developing some maturity. This
is a sector that places regulation and policy at the forefront
of supply and demand, and a change in policy will feed into
fundamentals very quickly. There are of course outside aspects
such as the recession, which in all certainty will reduce
factory output in the more developed countries, which will
then reduce electricity usage and emissions which will possibly
keep companies below the emission threshold above which they
would be expected to employ mitigation strategies. What would
be interesting to see, would be if the policy makers and the
politicians stimulate the carbon market – and global
emission reduction plans – by now reducing those threshold
limits to encourage companies to again start buying carbon
credits anew. It’s controversial to say such things,
as many would argue that those companies because of their
lower production are losing money and to add to their burden
would be unconscionable, but that is not the argument I am
posing. I am hopefully making it clear that policy and regulation
drives the carbon market like no other market.
(1)
Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change Fourth Assessment
Report climate Change 2007:Synthesis Report Summary for Policymakers,
Geneva, Switzerland, 2007.
(2) ASIGSA
|