Does
Gender matter for Financial Advice?
Jordy Hopkins
University of Johannesburg
Dr P.C. de Goeij
Universiteit van Tilbur

 raditional
theories in economics and finance have argued for years that
factors, such as gender, have little influence on market behaviour.
However, gender and its influence on the financial world has
been one of the most widely studied areas in finance. Gender
effects are a multifaceted and complex phenomenon, contributing
significantly to a variety of studies. According to the reviewed
research, gender influences both the behaviour of investors
and financial professionals. In addition significant differences
have been found to exist in the way men and women process
information, make decisions and handle finances. More specifically
women, compared to men, have been found to be more risk-averse,
take less extreme decisions, behave more like another and
avoid competitive environments. An observable outcome of these
processes and gender attributes is through analysts recommendations.
In order to issue such recommendations on companies, large
amounts of information must be processed and evaluated by
security analysts. Consequently, the gender of the security
analyst will then impact this process. While many studies
investigate biases in analyst’s recommendation and accredit
the recommendations-generating process to gender differences
and behavioural reasons, they neglect to consider how the
perception of these different recommendations could be impacted
by gender.
The view that all investors behave rationally is no longer
the general assumption. Recent findings in behavioural finance
provide alternative explanations for how and why investor’s
trade and behave in the market, observe and process data and
make financial decisions. Furthermore, they analyze how this
behaviour influences the financial markets.
Behavioural finance has made significant contributions to
both empirical research and financial theory. In particular
it explains how market participants use their own biases and
problem solving skills when they form beliefs, analyze and
process information. According to traditional theories, factors
such as the way in which information is presented, or more
accurately known as framing, should not impact the decisions
of investors. Framing however, has found support under behavioural
finance, which has used it to explain various anomalies found
in the market. Research has shown that various frames can
be used to generate certain responses and instead of adding
something new to an individual’s belief, frames tend
to trigger existing ones and induce other insights.
Socioeconomic factors and psychological determinants
were found to have more influence on consumer behaviour than
it was originally believed. The role that psychology plays
in the consumer market was examined by making slight changes
to both presentation and description of the information. It
was found that consumer behaviour can change in ways contradicting
the standard economic models. Consequently this has an impact
on the decision-making and behaviour of consumers and investors.
Reviewing the evidence it is clear that significant
differences exists in the way men and women process information,
make decisions and handle finances. However, despite extensive
research in gender differences, little or no studies have
been done on how investors perceive the handling of finances
by each gender. As a result of this, a research study was
conducted to observe how investors evaluate the recommendations
from male and female analysts. Through the use of an online
questionnaire a number of South African university students,
studying various finance and economics degrees, were asked
to choose either buy or sell recommendation given by two analysts.
The gender of the analysts were alternated, so that either
a buy recommendation was given by a male analyst and a sell
recommendation was given by the female analyst, or vice versa.
The study indicates that on average more
South Africans will buy shares when recommendations are given
by male analysts; however, if people have a low tolerance
to risk they will have a tendency to choose recommendations
given by female analysts. In addition, when information is
framed more negatively recommendations given by female analysts
are more likely to be chosen, whereas when information is
framed more positively, recommendations from male analysts
are chosen more often. However, those with a low risk tolerance,
show a tendency to take the opposite approach, that is they
tend to choose male analyst recommendations when information
is given more negatively and female analyst recommendations
when information is given more positively. From this study
it can then be seen that incorporating a gender frame can
influence the reaction and acceptance of financial advice.
Understanding and recognizing how investors
respond to certain factors overall, and gaining a better understanding
of the behavioural process is vital for financial professionals.
Identifying factors, such as gender, that contribute to the
behaviour of investors has important implications for both
the market and market participants alike. Furthermore, identifying
a consumer’s or investor’s characteristics is
important for understanding their actions in the market. From
the research and empirical evidence of numerous studies it
can be confidently stated that gender has an impact on the
decision-making process and behaviour of investors. Thus,
gaining an understanding in how investors perceive the advice
from both male and female analysts is important for financial
institutions, investors, financial analysts and for behavioural
finance as an academic discipline.
|