What
should investors know before they invest in unlisted securities?
By Elmarie Kruger
Manager Capital Markets Department, FSB

 nlisted
securities are shares in public or private companies not listed
on an exchange licensed by the FSB or not included in the
list of securities kept by an exchange. Trading in these securities
takes place over-the-counter.
Legislative
background
The Companies
Act, 1973
The trading of unlisted securities is regulated
in terms of the Companies Act, 1973, which is administered
by the Department of Trade and Industry. All companies in
South Africa must be registered with the Registrar of Companies
and must comply with all the relevant provisions of the Companies
Act. The Registrar of Companies has the power to investigate
any contraventions of this Act.
The Securities
Services Act, 2004 (SSA)
The objects of the SSA are to —
increase confidence in South African financial
markets by requiring fair, efficient and transparent securities
services which contribute to the maintenance of a stable financial
market environment;
- promote the protection of regulated persons and clients;
- reduce systemic risk; and
- promote international competitiveness of securities
services.
The SSA regulates “securities services”,
being services regarding the buying and selling of securities,
the custody and administration of securities, the management
of securities by a member of an exchange, and the clearing
and settlement of transactions in listed securities.
The term “securities” includes
shares, stocks and depository receipts in public companies
and other equivalent equities, notes, derivatives instruments,
bonds, debentures, participatory interests in a collective
investment scheme and instruments based on an index, but specifically
excludes money market instruments (except regarding the custody
and administration of securities).
The SSA regulates the trading of unlisted
securities to some extent. Section 20 of the SSA states that
the Registrar of Security Services may prohibit a person from
buying or selling unlisted securities if such business defeats
the objects of the Act. The Registrar may also impose conditions
for the carrying on of such business or may prescribe conditions
where specified types of unlisted securities may be bought
or sold. This is a reactive approach compared to the regulation
of listed securities as the FSB does not license such business
up front.
Unlisted companies are entitled to facilitate
the buying and selling of their own securities to investors.
However, companies are not allowed to operate an exchange
without being licensed by the FSB. The SSA defines an exchange
as someone who constitutes, maintains and provides an infrastructure
–
- for bringing together buyers and sellers of securities;
- for matching the orders for securities of multiple
buyers and sellers; and
- whereby a matched order for securities constitutes
a transaction.
Financial Advisory
and Intermediary Services Act, 2002 (FAIS Act)
The FAIS Act regulates the rendering of financial
advisory and intermediary services to clients. The Act’s
main objectives are to protect the interests of consumers
and to professionalise the financial services industry.
In terms of the FAIS Act nobody is allowed
to render financial services regarding financial products
as a regular feature of his or her business without being
authorised as a financial services provider or appointed as
a representative of an authorised provider.
Shares in a company other than a ‘share
block company’ as defined in the Share Blocks Control
Act, 1990, and any product issued by a foreign product supplier
and marketed in South Africa which is similar to a “share
in a company”, qualifies as a financial product. Therefore,
the FAIS Act regulates the rendering of financial services
to clients with respect to unlisted shares in public and private
companies (local or foreign).
Consumers who wish to conduct financial services
business with an institution or person are advised to check
beforehand with the FSB whether such an institution or person
is authorised to render financial services, or if the institution
or person is appointed as a representative of an authorised
financial services provider.
Risks of trading
in unlisted securities
There are a number of risks investors should
take into consideration before investing in unlisted securities.
A few important ones are discussed below.
Lack of a regulatory
framework
- Investors do not enjoy the same protection by the SSA
and the protection mechanisms provided by a licensed exchange,
eg many deals are done by private placing companies which
do not have to publish a prospectus.
- Unlisted securities are issued by companies that either
choose not to, or are unable to meet the stringent listing
requirements of licensed exchanges. Unlisted securities
are not subject to the same substantive requirements.
Listed companies must meet minimum listing standards such
as having minimum amounts of capital. Conversely, unlisted
companies do not have to meet any minimum standards. Disclosure
requirements for unlisted securities are less stringent
compared to listed securities.
- Since the market for unlisted securities are usually
controlled by a single market maker, the securities are
subject to price manipulation. The brokers on the inside
can create false volume by trading among themselves, artificially
raising the price on little volume and in the classic
“pump and dump” scams, once they inflate the
price, such brokers will dump their securities to unsuspecting
investors. Such investors will find that once they buy
these securities there are no other buyers, with the result
that the price will plummet. The provisions of the SSA
to take action against market abuse practices, such as
insider trading, market manipulation and the publication
of misleading statements, do not apply to the trading
of unlisted securities.
Lack of a formal
market
As there is no formal market for unlisted
securities, the risks of such an investment are greater. Investors
may have difficulty in selling their unlisted securities as
they first have to find a buyer for these securities. Trade
takes place directly between buyers and sellers.
Pricing and
liquidity risks
- There may be little or no liquidity in unlisted securities
and it may be difficult to establish a robust market price
for them. Many unlisted securities are relatively illiquid
or “thinly traded”. This could enhance the
volatility of the share price and make it difficult to
sell the securities at a later date.
- The valuation of unlisted securities is more difficult
to calculate than listed securities and the use of leverage
may amplify a fund's volatility. Valuations may be misleading.
Prices quoted in some unlisted securities may be historical
only and may not reflect recent trading in the company
concerned.
- Transparency of the unlisted securities market is not
done through the systems of the exchanges. Prices are
therefore not openly displayed. There is a risk that brokers
and dealers are not aware of all the trading in unlisted
securities and that customers are being disadvantaged
by reliance on incomplete volume and price information.
- Exchange securities prices are quoted regularly in newspapers
that allow investors to keep track of the prices of their
securities. Since unlisted securities are not traded in
an open market investors must rely upon their broker’s
information.
Difficult to
realise profits
It is difficult to realise profits because
the securities are thinly traded and the spread between the
bid price and ask price is large. This is not the case with
exchange traded securities since there is a real market, not
controlled by brokers.
Higher business
risk
Many OTC issuers are small to medium unlisted public and private
companies with limited operating history. They may also be
economically distressed and investment in these companies
often leads to a total loss.
Guidelines
for investing in unlisted securities
The following guidelines will assist investors
to make an informed investment decision:
- Investors should ensure that the company is reputable
and is registered with the Office of the Registrar of
Companies.
- Establish in which assets the company invests.
- Be aware of being offered spectacular returns. Remember
if it is too good to be true, it usually is.
- Never buy any securities without first evaluating the
fundamentals of the company. Investors should carefully
review the financial statements, management background
and other data before making an investment decision.
- Get a copy of the company’s prospectus.
- Get information on the directors of the company and
make sure that they are reputable persons who are fit
and proper.
- Study the products and services being rendered by the
company and make sure the company is not an empty shell.
- Make sure that the company exists by calling the company
secretary and establishing whether it has a website.
- Get information on the auditors of the company and
discuss the future prospects of the company with them.
- Study media releases issued by the company.
- Beware of promises that the unlisted company will soon
be listed on an exchange and that investors will make
big profits. Contact the exchange concerned and establish
whether an application for a listing has been received.
|