Effective
Managerial Leadership as a catalyst to the creation of high
performance teams
By Ms. T. van Staden
Absa

Abstract
he
research is based on growing a dysfunctional team into to
a high performance team with the implementation of managerial
leadership. Prior to the creation of the team used for the
study, the functions of the team were split over various business
units. As the company grew, it became impossible to manage
the delivery in this fashion, thus a dedicated team was created.
Due to change in the original management there was no team
structure, or proper management in place. The team was plagued
by internal strife.
This research proposes to show that effective
leadership in conjunction with proper management acts as the
catalyst for improvement of dysfunctional teams to becoming
high performance teams. This will affect the overall mood
of the individuals of the team, motivating them to deliver
better quality work and thus creating satisfied customers.
The company will benefit from satisfied customers, as well
as improved staff retention and intellectual capital.
Introduction
Background
The field of study explores the impact that
effective leadership in combination with successful management
(as opposed to effective leadership versus successful management)
has on the evolution of dysfunctional teams to high performance
teams. The specific case study is based on the evolution of
the IMAC Team (Team responsible for Installs, Moves, Additions
and Changes), an operational team within Internet Solutions
(IS), from a dysfunctional, non-performing, segregated team
to a point where the team functions as a unit with continuing
service improvement as a goal. Internet Solutions is one of
the largest suppliers of Convergent Communication Services
to the South African corporate market.
The IMAC Team was created in 2005 as part
of the strategic drive to improve the way IS provides service
to their clients. IMAC was supposed to ensure accountability
across business units for different products and services
sold to the clients. The team members were the people who
were responsible for the work prior to the change. The affected
employees were not given a choice in the matter of moving.
If they did not want to move, they had to find another position.
The first manager of the IMAC was knowledgeable
regarding processes and procedures. She managed an accounting
team prior to IMAC. Employees were moved from business units
to the new team on a weekly basis. The first manager stayed
in the role for six months. Her approach was solid and unemotional,
rational and focused. She was considerate to the staff and
had a solid management background. The team did well. Unfortunately,
she was moved back to manage a team in the accounting department.
An internal candidate from IMAC replaced her. The new manager
did not have enough experience in managing teams. According
to senior managers, she was easily influenced. She made emotional
decisions and was prone to emotional outbursts in the office.
She did not follow human resource (HR) policies and protocols.
After three months, the team as well as the manager were falling
apart. The manager resigned and left IS.
The aim of the team had not changed since
inception, but the workload, the complexities of work and
expectations from the team members had been hugely underestimated.
Underdelivery snowballed rapidly. Human resource issues were
not addressed rapidly enough, causing increasing unhappiness.
Serious growth in the company increased the stresses. It appeared
that there were no processes or structures in place, no support
for the team was visible and no team spirit existed. Very
few signs of leadership or management were evident. The team
was clearly divided into various cliques. Racial issues and
nepotism existed. The atmosphere was tense and unpleasant.
This severely impacted the quality of work being delivered.
Senior management realized that it was going
to be an extremely difficult task to salvage what was left
of the team. The third manager was an external appointment,
as there was a need for someone objective, without the baggage
of coming from a different department within the company.
The third manager was chosen with the use of extensive psychometric
testing and various interviews with different levels of management.
The candidates’ profile showed that she had strong leadership
capabilities, was focused and was unemotional. She had the
ability to make difficult decisions and implement them.
After employing effective leadership and
proper management techniques, the team was restructured, and
new processes implemented. This not only led to the team operating
as a unit, but also being more productive and achieving better
results. The negative perception that the rest of the company
had of the team slowly changed to a more positive one. With
the support and backing of management, the team members were
treated with the respect and trust they deserved. This improved
their feeling of self-worth as well as the overall team satisfaction
levels. The team was well on its way to becoming a high performance
team. Once team satisfaction improved a ripple effect was
experienced where customer satisfaction improved in accordance.
Objectives
of the study
The key research objectives of this study
are the following:
- To establish the role of leadership versus management
in operational teams, does one need a leader or a manager
or both?
- To establish if the implementation of effective leadership
in conjunction with successful management can act as the
catalyst to improve team dynamics and creating high performance
teams.
- To show that with improved structure and processes
the individuals in a team can be motivated to work together
towards a common goal. To investigate if there is a link
between Emotional Intelligence of team members and the
general satisfaction of the team.
- To demonstrate that increased team satisfaction has
a positive influence on customer satisfaction.
- To deduce that investment in leadership and management
is conducive to positive growth in teams as well as companies.
- To postulate that employee satisfaction has a beneficial
effect on the bottom line of the company.
Scope of the
study
The scope of the study is to demonstrate
how managerial leadership acts as the catalyst to the creation
of high performance teams. Team performance can in turn be
linked to the satisfaction levels of employees (team members)
and customers.
The question will be examined if it is possible
that when team members are satisfied this has a positive impact
on the emotional intelligence of the individuals in the team?
Such an increase in EQi would serve as motivation to perform
better which, in turn leads to improved customer satisfaction.
Research questions
of the study
The research question forming the crux of
the research study reads as follows: “Can team and customer
satisfaction be improved by implementing effective leadership
and successful management through deploying strategic processes,
and thus ensuring positive growth of the company?”
Research Methodology
& Design
This research was conducted in the social
world; it is theoretical / empirical in nature and used both
quantitative and qualitative research paradigms. Case study
research served as the primary research paradigm in this research.
Sampling and
Scaling
For the ambit of the research conducted,
the following population sizes were used:
- The Team satisfaction survey, N<50, the entire team
was surveyed.
- The Customer satisfaction survey – around 100,
75% of the population of internal customers to the IMAC
Team was surveyed.
For the research conducted, the following
scaling technique used:
- The IMAC Team Satisfaction survey was not done according
to a Likert scaling technique.
- A five point Likert scaling technique was used to capture
the Internal Customer Survey respondents’ opinions
on questions posed in an attempt to answer the research
questions.
Characteristics/demographic
information of respondents
The respondents were divided into two groups.
The first group is the IMAC Team. The second group is the
Internal Customers of the IMAC Team. The groups are both employees
of Internet Solutions. Satisfaction surveys were distributed
to each group (see
Appendices 1 & 2).
For this research, the following classifications
of respondents were used in designing the questionnaire:
- Biographic details
- Age group
- Gender
- Demographic details
Biographic
details
The biographic details of the survey cover
the location of the survey respondents.
- IMAC Team Satisfaction survey
The IMAC Team members were located at the head office
in Bryanston, Gauteng, as well as the regional offices
located in Cape Town, Port Elizabeth and Durban.
- Customer Satisfaction Survey
This group of respondents are all Internet Solutions employees.
They are located at the head office and regional offices
of the company. The head office is located in Bryanston,
Gauteng. The regional offices are located in Cape Town,
Port Elizabeth and Durban. Employees from all the centres
took part in the survey.
Age group
The age group depicts the average age of
the survey respondents. The age groups for the two surveys
differ substantially:
- IMAC Team Satisfaction survey
The average age of the IMAC Team is approximately 25 years
old.
- Customer Satisfaction Survey
The age of the second group varies more widely, as this
group consists of Account Managers, Accounting Staff and
Technical staff that deal with the IMAC Team. The averages
age for this group is estimated at 36 years old. Internet
Solutions is known to be a “young environment”
– meaning a lot of their employees are younger.
Gender
The gender of the respondents is recorded
for statistical purposes.
- IMAC Team Satisfaction survey
The IMAC Team consists of female staff members only.
- Customer Satisfaction Survey
The customer group is a mixed group. Respondents were
50% male and 50% female.
Demographic
details
The demographic details of the respondents
relate to the structure of the groups that partook in the
surveys.
- IMAC Team Satisfaction survey
The IMAC Team consists of younger staff with less business
experience. The IMAC position can be viewed as level 1
or entry level position.
- Customer Satisfaction Survey
The Account Managers in the second group are customer
orientated executives. This position is normally viewed
as a more senior position. The Technical staff and Accounting
staff are specialists in their field, thus also are in
more senior positions.
Tools and Measurements
of the case study
The IMAC Team survey was conducted at three
different times; August 2006, October 2006 and February 2007.
The Customer Satisfaction Survey was conducted in December
2006 and March 2007. The Customer Satisfaction Surveys were
utilised to establish if there was an improvement in the satisfaction
of the IMAC Team as well as the Internal Customers due to
the implementation of managerial leadership.
Other instruments were utilized that are
relevant to the case study and in proving that Managerial
Leadership can act as a catalyst to creating high performance
teams.
Research questions
The aim of the study is to show that managerial
leadership can act as a catalyst to the creation of high performance
teams. The success of various measures implemented will be
measured by satisfaction surveys internally in the team and
in the company.
Research question
1
Can the implementation of effective leadership
along with proper management act as catalyst for a dysfunctional
team to evolve into a high performance team?
- Relevant IMAC Team Survey Questions:
- I feel significant actions have been taken where
I work as a result of previous
feedback.
- Managers of this organization support diversity
in the workplace.
Research question
2
How does one create a high performance team?
- Relevant IMAC Team Survey Questions:
- I understand and know my department strategy and
how it fits into the organization.
- People in my department are encouraged to come
up with new, creative solutions to work related problems.
- Sufficient effort is being made to simplify the
way we work in this department.
- Relevant Customer Satisfaction Survey Questions:
- Is the feedback provided by the IMAC Team relevant
and frequent?
- Are the jobs opened accurately in Siebel, first
time round?
- How willing is the IMAC Team to assist with queries
and escalations?
Research question
3
How does working in a high performance team
affect job satisfaction for the team members?
- Relevant IMAC Team Survey Questions:
- How do you rate your total benefits.
- Most of the time it is safe to speak up in my organization.
- Relevant Customer Satisfaction Survey Questions:
- Do you experience the IMAC Team as being helpful
and friendly
Research question
4
What is the ultimately benefit to the organization
in investing in the leadership and management training of
their employees?
- Relevant IMAC Team Survey Questions:
- I believe I have the opportunity in IS for personal
development and growth in the future.
- In my opinion this organization does a good job
of promoting the most competent people.
Research question
5
Does improvement in team satisfaction impact
customer satisfaction and ultimately the bottom line?
- Relevant IMAC Team Survey Questions:
- I am proud to be associated with IS as a whole.
- Relevant Customer Satisfaction Survey Questions:
- Does the IMAC Team provide a professional service?
- Do you experience the IMAC Team as being helpful
and friendly?
- Is the feedback provided by the IMAC Team relevant
and frequent?
- Are the jobs opened accurately in Siebel, first
time round?
- How willing is the IMAC Team to assist with queries
and escalations?
- Does the IMAC Team take ownership of jobs from
inception to billing?
Conclusions
& Recommendations
Discussion
of results
The transformation of the IMAC Team resulted
in a change of perception of the team throughout the organization.
Their clients, namely Account Managers, Accounting staff and
Technical staff, recognized an improved performance of its
role by the IMAC Team: no longer were there delays of months,
errors in data capturing and lack of follow up and feedback.
This was achieved by employing a manager
who was able to provide leadership and implement structure
and processes in an objective maner. With support and guidelines,
the team was able to perform better. As additional staff was
employed (capacity building) the workload was reduced and
team members were able to complete their day to day tasks,
which in turn led to shorter turn around times for the clients
to receive the service they had ordered. Greater efficiency
and effectiveness was thus achieved.
Human Resource issues were addressed and
the team was soon transformed from a divided team to a united
team. Racial issues and nepotism were resolved with careful
management over a period of time.
Discussion
of outcome of results of research question 1
Can the implementation of effective leadership
along with proper management act as catalyst for a dysfunctional
team to evolve into a high performance team?
The research conducted revealed that effective
managerial leadership can act as a catalyst for the creation
of a high performance team. This was evidenced in the positive
shifts of perceptions, opinions, and feelings captured in
the results of the satisfaction surveys.
Discussion
of outcome of results of research question 2
How does one create a high performance
team?
To be able to build a high performance team,
it is imperative for the manager of the team to believe in
one’s people. Building a relationship that has abundant
communication and trust is crucial for creating a high performance
team.
Discussion
of outcome of results of research question 3
How does working in a high performance
team affect job satisfaction for the team members?
The Satisfaction Surveys documented in this
research programme indicated that there is a direct link between
the job satisfaction of the IMAC Team and the improvement
of the team towards a high performance team. The indication
was that team members were more satisfied in general with
their working conditions. Refer to Appendices 1 and 2 for
the IMAC Team Satisfaction Survey and Internal Customer Satisfaction
Survey.
Discussion
of outcome of results of research question 4
What is the ultimate benefit to the organization
of investing in the training of leadership and management
of their employees?
Investing in training for the management
team ensures that the management team grows. This investment
filters down to the work teams, and allows for successful
work teams and increased job satisfaction. Ensuring an organization
remains a learning organization is crucial for growth and
prosperity. Furthermore, as evidenced by the various personality
assessments that were carried out (MBTI and EQi; and job competency
fit), these aspects remain crucial to ensure a project team
has a competent managerial leader.
Discussion
of outcome of results of research question 5
Does improvement in team satisfaction
impact customer satisfaction and ultimately the bottom line?
According to the case study, the team satisfaction
directly impacted the customer satisfaction. According to
the research quoted, studies have shown that the bottom line
of a company is linked to customer satisfaction. It can thus
be deduced that the improvement of the team satisfaction will
have positive outcomes for the organization’s bottom
line.
Conclusions
The implementation of managerial leadership
can benefit organizations. The employees of the organization
will be more satisfied leading to better production. The ripple
effect of this is that:
- The customers will be satisfied.
- Project rollout is on time (cost saving).
- Greater efficiency and problem solving skills are acquired,
leading to increased profitability.
Recommendations
It is recommended that the processes and
structure implemented at the IMAC Team be maintained to ensure
that the team does not stagnate or fall back into old habits.
The manager of the team needs to ensure that enough time and
effort are invested into the team members for sustainability,
to sufficiently anchor the new behaviours. Team members need
to feel that they are appreciated and valued and that the
work they do is of continuous value adding importance to the
organization.
Lastly there can be great merit for the organization
to apply on a larger scale throughout all divisions within
the organization what has been learnt from this single team
research study into the improvement of team performance, leadership,
and customer service. It may be worth mentioning that since
the manager of this team left for another position at a different
organization, that the team’s performance deteriorated.
This was later turned around again when it was recognized
that personality assessment and job matching is critically
important, as there is a link between ability (job competency)
and managerial leadership performance.
Bibliography
- Alexander, G & Renshaw, B. 2005. Super
Coaching. The Missing Ingredient for High
Performance. London: Random House Business Books.
- Cranfield University School of management.
2008. Lead and motivate your staff. [Online],
Available from:
http://www.businesslink.gov.uk/bdotg/action/detail?r.l1=1074404796&r.l3=1077340364&r.lc=en&type=RESOURCES&itemId=1077340517&r.l2=1074450305&r.s=sc
[Accessed on 20/08/2008]
- Department of State Civil Service. 2007.
Introduction to job profiling. Louisiana: Baton Rouge (Study
Guide Course Text 11 April 2007).
- Flanagan, N. & Finger, J. 2000. Just
about everything a manager needs to know in South Africa.
Cape Town: Zebra Press.
- Hsu, S.C. & Mujtaba, B.G. 2007. Team
Transformational Leadership, Trust, Satisfaction, And Commitment:
The Testing Of a Structural Equation Model in Software Development
- Teams. [Online]. Available from: http://www.cluteinstitute-onlinejournals.com/PDFs/258.pdf
[Accessed on 07/08/2008]
- Kolbe, K. (1993). Pure Instinct: The M.O.
of High Performance People and Teams. Phoenix, Arizona:
Monumentus Press.
- Kotelnikov, V. 2008. Managerial Leadership
[Online]. Available from: http://www.1000ventures.com/business_guide/crosscuttings/leadership_managerial.html
[Accessed on 07/08/2008]
- Kreitner R. & Kinicki A. 2004 Organizational
Behavior, New York: McGraw Hill.
- Lynch, R. 2006. Corporate Strategy. Essex:
Pearson Education Limited.
- MindTools. 1995-2008. Leadership Styles,
Using the right one for your situation. [Online]. Available
from: http://www.mindtools.com/pages/article/newLDR_84.htm
[Accessed on 25/10/2008]
- Rance, D. 2008. If you want to Improve
Your Bottom Line, Invest in Your Customer Service. [Online].
Available from: http://www.customerthink.com/blog/improve_bottom_line_invest_customer_service
[Accessed on 12/08/2008]
- Steyn, P., Schmikl, E. 2005. Creating high
performance project and process teams. Cranefield Institute
of Management (Study Guide Module M5) Suterwala, S. 2008.
TIPS: TEAM follow the acronym of PERFORM [Online]. Available
from: http://shabbarsuterwala.blogspot.com/2007_11_01_archive.html
[Accessed on 13/09/2008]
- Teamtechnology.co.uk. 1995. Leadership
Styles. Based on Myers Briggs/Jung Typology. [Online]. Available
from: http://www.teamtechnology.co.uk/leadership-styles.html
[Accessed on 25/10/2008]
- Today’s Leadership Coaching. 2003-2006.
High performance team coaching: Developing leadership skills.
[Online]. Available from: http://www.todaysleadership.com/effective_leadership_team_coaching.html
[Accessed on 17/10/2008]
|